WS-BaseNotification

Number

Description

Status – draft j

Status - draft k

1.4

Support for Pull-type notification

Matt: Add description of how to use the interfaces

Done

Matt: Add /any to the pseudo-schemas

Done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

Matt: Is a PullPoint normatively required to support Notify from third parties?

Not addressed

Matt: No discussion of the Initial Termination time for a PP

Not addressed

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

1.5

Term “Event” is not clearly defined

OK

2.1

Topics are not optional in WS-BaseNotification

David S: Remove “in order for the notification message to be sent” from the description of wsnt:/Filter.

Not done

Tom: Make FixedTopicSet optional with default of true

Done

2.6

Third party subscriber can be a security concern

Tom:concern that the text does not match the agreed approach

Not addressed

David S: Remove references to WS-Trust and WS-SecureConversation

Not done

David S: Typo in 7,2, WS-those

Not done

2.23

Is subscription a WS-Resource?

Tom: ResumeSubscription says that it MUST implement WSRAP

Done

Rick:469-472 say that it is

Done

2.25

Indirection via WSRF-RP and WSRL

Sanjay:Text needs to make it clear that it’s ok for an NP not to support any WSN RPs

Sanjay to verify

2.32

Dialect of TopicExpression in Subscribe MUST be specified

OK

2.33

Message ordering/interleaving

Susan/John:Add message ordering to non-goals section

Done

2.34

Additional Fault definitions

Susan: MultipleTopicsSpecifiedFault missing from Schema and WSDL

Not done

Peter: suffix "Fault" missing from name of several faults in 4.2, 5.1.4, 5.2, 6.1.1, 6.1.2

Not done

2.36

Specify baseline Policy behaviour

OK

2.39

Tighten up semantics of send/deliver

Rick:Instance of "send" in 4.2 (under ConsumerReference)

Not done

Rick:Instance of "send" in 7.2

Done

Matt: Suggest changing “deliver” to "produce"

Done

2.41

Use of wsrf-rp:Dialect

OK

2.43

Message generation and accumulation styles

OK

2.45

Typing of Notification payload – xs:any vs xs:anyType

OK

2.46

Should UseNotify be a policy utterance?

OK

2.47

Open content on messages

Mark: Need descriptions of the extensibility /any in text of the 9 requests and their responses

Not done

2.48

Define action URI for fault messages and update the spec text to use wsa:Action

Tom: Should refer to wsa MAPs

Done, except for the 3 pull subscription operations

Tom: missing URI on unsubscribe response (6.1.2)

Done

2.49

Define faults exhaustively (no silent faults)

OK

2.50

Update non-normative examples

Susan:Still some ref props in examples of Notify and SubscribeResponse

Done

2.51

Flexible placing of metadata

OK

2.52

TopicExpressionDialects to be singular

John:Need to make minOccurs="0" in schema and xsd

Not done

2.53

Use TopicExpression instead of TopicPathExpression

OK

2.54

Use WS-Resource defined ResourceUnknownFaultType

OK

2.55

Remove references to specs that aren't in standards orgs

Tom:Move SOAP11, SOAP12 references to non-normative

Done

David S: Replace the unresolved [WSRF] reference at the start of section 6

Not done

David S: remove refs to WS-Policy etc from the requirements section (1.1.1)

Not done

David S: generalize ref to WS-Policy in wsnt:SubscriptionPolicy text

Not done

AI 82

Incorporate material from White Paper

OK

AI 97

Update status paragaph

That->this

Not done