Attendance
|
William Cox |
BEA |
|
|
|
Graeme Riddell |
Bowstreet |
Y |
|
|
Greg Giles |
Cisco |
|
|
|
Srinivas Vadhri |
Commerce One |
|
|
|
Kirk Wilson |
Computer Associates |
|
|
|
Sean Fitts |
Crossweave |
|
|
|
Timothy N. Jones |
Crossweave |
Y |
|
|
Peter Quintas |
Divine |
|
|
|
Sandra Swearingen |
DoD |
|
|
|
Monica Martin |
Drake Certivo |
Y |
|
|
Alan Kropp |
Epicentric |
|
|
|
Patel Ashish |
France Telecom |
|
|
|
Aditi Karandikar |
France Telecom |
|
|
|
Royston Sellman |
HP |
Y |
|
|
Eric van Lyndegraf |
Kinzan |
|
|
|
Charles Wiecha |
IBM (chair) |
Y |
|
|
Dan Gisolfi |
IBM |
|
|
|
Ravi Konuru |
IBM |
Y |
|
|
Rich Thompson |
IBM |
Y |
|
|
Shankar Ramaswamy |
IBM |
Y |
|
|
T.V. Raman |
IBM |
|
|
|
Rex Brooks |
individual |
Y |
|
|
John Kneiling |
individual |
|
|
|
Kevin Brinkley |
Intel |
|
|
|
Michael Mahan |
Nokia |
|
|
|
Martin Chapman |
Oracle |
|
|
|
Terry Cline |
Peregrine Systems |
Y |
|
|
Sasha Aicken |
Plumtree |
|
|
|
Stefan Beck |
SAP |
Y |
|
|
Howard Melman |
Silverstream |
|
|
|
Jeffrey C. Broberg |
Silverstream |
Y |
|
|
Suresh Damodaran |
Sterling Commerce |
|
|
|
Eilon Reshef |
WebCollage |
|
|
|
Gil Tayar |
WebCollage |
|
|
Agenda
1.
Roll call and minutes - Graeme
2.
Reminder on F2F logistics: Wed 6/26 Joint
Interfaces discussion together with WSRP, 6/27 Customized requirements - Rich
3.
Update on Embedded interfaces - Rich
4.
Update on Customized requirements - Eilon
5.
Update on WSIA specific interfaces - Ravi
6.
Update on Security - Rich
7. Glossary - Jeff
Meeting
12:00
roll call
12:05
review of minutes and actions from last
meeting.
Minutes
approved. Actions all set, except:
12:05
>F2F logisitics
WSRP/WSIA
joint committee expecting to meet on Wednesday of the F2F, then WSIA in full on
Thursday and Friday.
Suggestion
that since WSRP and WSIA are biweekly they could share the same Thurday 12 EDT
timeslot.
action: Rich ö
to fire off a note to confirm move to this time, starting Thursday May 23
(Note,
between meeting time and these minutes being written this time change was
dropped. Keeping current Friday biweekly schedule until F2F).
12:10
Status of Embedded ö Rich
WSIA/WSRP
Joint Interfaces and Protocols discussing merger of WSXL and IWS documents.
Have done a high-level pass, discovered clash of terminology between (eg,
ãinstanceä), cued up for discussion on Tuesday. The merged doc is now in a
joint draft document. WSIA have discussed need for persisting data and good
terminology is being deliberated there too.
WSRP Security
had a ãRoleä discussion. Producers will want to declare roles, and Consumers
will need to map roles that he supports to those the Provider supports. The
interface in WSRP would stay the same, but the resultant markup might change
based on the Consumerâs role.
Q: WSRP have a
draft document yet?
A: No, only
concrete thing is the RPWS doc, they are stillworking at an abstract level.
Likely that our doc will drive into WSRP to support their requirements.
Aiming to get
our draft document out onto the list for review a couple of weeks ahead of the
F2F.
Need to
separate Embedded from WSRP at some point. Aiming to make sure WSRP can build
on whatever Embedded defines.
12:25
Status of Customized ö Charlie
Target for F2F
is to have draft for internal review. Developing set of sub-scenarios,
something in between earlier scenarios and technical requirements. Simpler
subsets to use for more detailed requirements, currently have 8 ö 10
submissions. Pete Quintas has some multimodal scenarios, Eilon some from
configurator space.
Making
progress and refining ideas right now. Will send out latest doc and minutes to
the general list.
action: subcommittee leads ö please send out minutes
from subcommittee meetings to the general list to help everyone else to track
and give feedback
12:30
WSIA WSDL-specific interfaces ö Ravi
Had 2
meetings, problem that no concrete stuff has come out of other WSIA
subcommittees yet. so nothing concrete for this subcommittee to work on.
Decision was taken in the subcommittee to keep the subcommittee active but to
suspend meetings for the time being, until more specific (eg Customized)
requirements appear. Probably no action in this subcommitte now until after the
F2F.
12:35
Security ö Rich
Drew up a
significant reading list and have now moved to a biweekly meeting. Need
discussion next on general security. Howard M from Silverstream has joind the
subcommittee and is contributing valuable input.
Q: Need to
align with WS-Security?
A: It focuses
on how other security mechanisms might be used in SOAP messaging. We need to
understand the WSIA interactions and then can understand which of WS-Security
recommendations are most relevant.
Q: WSRP
Security overlap?
A: Theyâre
currently focused on transference of identity and privacy.
action: Rich to sync up with Mark Cassidy, and to fwd
WSRP Security emails to the WSIA list.
12:40
>Glossary ö Jeff
Waiting on
some input from IBM right now, Dan G currently working on getting extra input.
Jeff adding new proposed definitions as terms of confusion arise.
12:42
Requirements doc status ö Rich
R602 is the
most controversial and is not closed yet. 10-15% of requirements marked as
needing discussion have not yet started discussion. Rich looking to remove
change marks and rearrange the doc by functional area.
12:45
adjourn