[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Handling the remaining open issues and our first Public Review
Hi, I have been looking through the 22
remaining open issues that we have for the SCA-J specification and I am very aware
that we need to have a Public Review Draft very soon. Currently, I feel that we
will not be able to resolve all the 22 open issues before we go to Public
Review. Currently we have told the Liaison committee that we will not reach the
original mid-March date and are now aiming to go for Public Review in mid-April To this end, as chairs we feel that as a
TC, we should: ·
Schedule
some more conference call times (will cover this in a separate discussion) ·
Concentrate
on what must be resolved before going to Public Review. I have been through all of the open issues
and prioritized them so we can focus our efforts with the remaining time. Below, I have listed the remaining open
issues: List A:
Issues that must resolve before Public Review These issues must be resolved before going
to Public Review. JAVA-104 RFC2119
Language is needed for CAA Specification JAVA-105 RFC2119
Language is needed for C&I Specification JAVA-119 JAA
Conformance Section In addition to the above issues, we need
to ensure that Test Assertions and Test Cases are written. There is currently
no issue open for this task. List B:
Issues that would be nice to resolve before Public Review It would be nice if the following issues were
resolved before going to Public Review. However, if they are not resolved, then
they are not critical enough to prevent the Public Review from taking place. JAVA-123 Java
C&I - Remove references to conversational function JAVA-39 Incorrect
example in Java Component Implementation Spec v1.00 - Sec 1.2.4 JAVA-129 Problems
with Example 2b in chapter 7 JAVA-54 Section
7.1 of the Java CAA Specification is unclear JAVA-38 Inconsistent
rules for the use of @reference annotation JAVA-65 There
is no lifecycle defined for SCA Components List C:
Issues that we could leave unresolved until after Public Review The following issues can remain unresolved
when going to Public Review. Starting from Monday 16th March, I am intending
to not schedule any call time before the Public Review for these issues unless all
the issues from List A and List B are resolved. JAVA-127 Long
running request/response operations JAVA-125 Allow
call semantics to be specified in interface.java JAVA-134 @Callback
and @Remotable on implementation classes JAVA-131 @Callback
injection could be NULL (expanded to include refs, property and re-injection
and callback ctor injection) JAVA-98 Can
annotations be inherited JAVA-1 Accessing
SCA Services from non-SCA component code JAVA-46 equals()
method on ServiceReference and CallableReference JAVA-139 Default
value for SCA property is not supported for java implementations JAVA-62 Clarify
what a Component Implementation can do with threads JAVA-78 Need
API to set EPR and for a reference invocation JAVA-51 More
examples on <interface.wsdl> mapping to Java JAVA-53 what
happens if init() throws a runtime exception (Blocked by JAVA-65) JAVA-13 ComponentContext.getProperty(...)
ill defined (Blocked by JAVA-138) I have tried to be as harsh as possible
with the above lists. Most of the nice to resolve issues are
“editorial” stuff to correct examples and clarify existing
functionality. Generally the issues in the defer list are new features or
enhancements to the current specification. I expect there may be some
disagreement with my classifications but feel free to raise any strong
disagreements that you may have. I would also like to encourage people to focus
their attention on the issues in List A and List B. This will maximise our ability
to resolve as many of the pressing issues before we go to Public Review. I am interested in people’s opinion on
the lists and whether with the above plan they feel that we can achieve our
Public Review date of mid-April? I certainly hope that we can. Thanks, Mark Mark Combellack| Software Developer| Avaya | |
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]