OASIS Open: Committees

SCA service wsdlElement pointing to a WSDL service

Do you think we should define the behaviour of wsdlElement on an SCA service pointing to a WSDL service, and if so, what should the behaviour be?

[ ]	We should disallow this case
[ ]	We should allow this case but say nothing
[ ]	We should allow this case and require the runtime to provide at least one of the ports, possibly more
[ ]	We should allow this case and require the runtime to provide all of the matching ports
[ ]	Other:

Opening:		Thursday, 2 April 2009 @ 01:00 pm EDT
Closing:		Thursday, 9 April 2009 @ 12:00 pm EDT
Group:		OASIS Service Component Architecture / Bindings (SCA-Bindings) TC

Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
We should disallow this case	9	56%
We should allow this case but say nothing	0	0%
We should allow this case and require the runtime to provide at least one of the ports, possibly more	0	0%
We should allow this case and require the runtime to provide all of the matching ports	6	38%
Other	1	6%

Eligible members who have voted:	10 of 17	59%
Eligible members who have abstained:	0 of 17	0%
Eligible members who have not voted:	7 of 17	41%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Tom Rutt	Fujitsu Limited	We should disallow this case
Mike Edwards	IBM	--
Piotr Przybylski	IBM	--
Michael Beisiegel	IBM	--
David Booz	IBM	We should disallow this case
Bryan Aupperle	IBM	We should disallow this case	Since a service is allowed to have multiple bindings, no functionality is lost (albeit at the cost of a bit more SCDL) and complexity is reduced by disallowing this case.
Simon Holdsworth	IBM	We should disallow this case We should allow this case and require the runti...
Simon Nash	Individual	We should allow this case and require the runti... Other: We should allow this case and say the runtime SHOULD provide all of the matching ports (as in the issue 54 proposal)
Martin Chapman	Oracle Corporation	--
Jeff Mischkinsky	Oracle Corporation	We should disallow this case We should allow this case and require the runti...
Ashok Malhotra	Oracle Corporation	We should disallow this case We should allow this case and require the runti...
Anish Karmarkar	Oracle Corporation	We should disallow this case We should allow this case and require the runti...	I think it is strange to specify absolute URLs for services. I know we already do that through other means (EPR, @uri attribute). To me, relative URIs are what makes sense on the service-side. When de
Khanderao Kand	Oracle Corporation	We should disallow this case We should allow this case and require the runti...	Agree with Anish's comments
Plamen Pavlov	SAP AG	--
Nimish Hathalia	TIBCO Software Inc.	--
Laurent Domenech	TIBCO Software Inc.	--
Eric Johnson	TIBCO Software Inc.	We should disallow this case	This seems like something that we SHOULD NOT be allowed rather than it MUST NOT be done.