OASIS Open: Committees

Sun 64-bit binary alignment proposal v2 document

Adopt the proposal as written in http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/32413/Sun%2064-bit%20Binary%20Alignment%20Proposal.pdf and assign to editors to fold into the core.

[ ]	Yes
[ ]	No
[ ]	Abstain

Opening:		Friday, 8 May 2009 @ 02:00 am EDT
Closing:		Friday, 15 May 2009 @ 02:00 am EDT
Group:		OASIS Key Management Interoperability Protocol (KMIP) TC

Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
Yes	19	56%
No	15	44%
Abstain	4

Eligible members who have voted:	34 of 42	81%
Eligible members who have abstained:	4 of 42	10%
Eligible members who have not voted:	4 of 42	10%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Marc Hocking	BeCrypt Ltd.	--
Scott Kipp	Brocade Communications Systems, Inc.	No	This is an unneeded optimization that causes unoptimization in other places.
Don McAlister	Cipheroptics	Yes
Landon Noll	Cisco Systems, Inc.	Yes
Rob Philpott	EMC Corporation	Yes
Robert Griffin	EMC Corporation	Yes
Servesh Singh	EMC Corporation	Yes
Shyam Mankala	EMC Corporation	Yes
Judith Furlong	EMC Corporation	Yes
David Lawson	Emulex Corporation	No
Larry Hofer	Emulex Corporation	No	I like the 8 byte header part of this proposal, but I voted no because a yes vote is to accept padding to 64 bits, which adds extra bytes per object over the 32 bit proposal. The extra bytes used in t
Mark Schiller	Hewlett-Packard	Yes
Stan Feather	Hewlett-Packard	Yes
Indra Fitzgerald	Hewlett-Packard	Yes
Steven Wierenga	Hewlett-Packard	Yes	I am voting "yes" for the tag/type/length 8-byte alignment. I would prefer 4-byte alignment for values, but I can accept 8-byte.
Krishna Yellepeddy	IBM	--
Glen Jaquette	IBM	--
Anthony Nadalin	IBM	No
Bruce Rich	IBM	No
Robert Haas	IBM	No
Mathias Bjorkqvist	IBM	No
Benjamin Tomhave	Individual	--
Marc Massar	Individual	Abstain
Walt Hubis	LSI Corporation	Yes
Thomas Hardjono	M.I.T.	Abstain
Elaine Barker	NIST	Abstain
Subhash Sankuratripati	NetApp	No
Will Price	PGP Corporation	No
Jon Callas	PGP Corporation	Yes
Rod Wideman	Quantum Corporation	Yes
Chris Dunn	SafeNet, Inc.	No
Alan Frindell	SafeNet, Inc.	No
Matthew Ball	Sun Microsystems	Yes
Sandy Stewart	Sun Microsystems	Yes
Wyllys Ingersoll	Sun Microsystems	Yes
Tom Clifford	Symantec Corp.	Abstain
Jonathan Geater	Thales e-Security	No
Marcus Streets	Thales e-Security	No
Kevin Bocek	Thales e-Security	No
Robert Lockhart	Thales e-Security	No	Cycles to parse 32 bit versus 64 bit aligned messages have not been clarified for me as to the specific issues. I am probably being a stick in the mud here but I would like to understand who will ben
Paul Turner	Venafi, Inc.	Yes
Peter Bartok	Venafi, Inc.	Yes