OASIS Open: Committees

Fulltext search expression

This ballot is to decide whether or not fulltext search expression should be specified in v1, and if yes, which of the three proposals described in cmis_fts_proposal_v0_3.txt is to be adopted. You may vote for up to three of the four choices. The one with most votes wins.

[ ]	"Proposal 0"
[ ]	"Proposal 1"
[ ]	"Proposal 2"
[ ]	Fulltext search expression should not be specified in v1

Opening:		Wednesday, 3 June 2009 @ 02:00 pm EDT
Closing:		Wednesday, 10 June 2009 @ 02:00 pm EDT
Group:		OASIS Content Management Interoperability Services (CMIS) TC

Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
"Proposal 0"	8	25%
"Proposal 1"	11	34%
"Proposal 2"	9	28%
Fulltext search expression should not be specified in v1	4	13%

Eligible members who have voted:	16 of 60	27%
Eligible members who have abstained:	0 of 60	0%
Eligible members who have not voted:	44 of 60	73%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Betsy Fanning	AIIM	"Proposal 1"
Celso Rodriguez	ASG Software Solutions	--
Philippe Allart	Adullact	--
Christophe Kijewska	Adullact	--
David Caruana	Alfresco Software	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
John Newton	Alfresco Software	--
Patrick Ward	Booz Allen Hamilton	--
Shane Johnson	Citytech, Inc.	"Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Matt van Bergen	Citytech, Inc.	--
Steffen Frederiksen	Content Technologies ApS	--
David Nuescheler	Day Software	--
Dominique Pfister	Day Software	--
Thomas Mueller	Day Software	--
Peeter Piegaze	Day Software	--
Michael Marth	Day Software	--
Angela Schreiber	Day Software	--
Oliver Walthard	Day Software	--
Cornelia Davis	EMC Corporation	--
David Choy	EMC Corporation	--
Craig Randall	EMC Corporation	Fulltext search expression should not be specif...
Norrie Quinn	EMC Corporation	Fulltext search expression should not be specif...	support in v2 - see JIRA comments
Marc Pallot	ESoCE-NET	--
Gregory Grefenstette	Exalead, Inc.	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Fred Boiscuvier	Exalead, Inc.	--
Spencer Shearer	Exalead, Inc.	--
Jason Dubreuil	Fidelity Investments	--
Kevin Dorr	Flatirons Solutions Corporation	--
Julian Reschke	Greenbytes GmbH	"Proposal 1"
Thomas Pole	Harris Corp	--
Al Brown	IBM	"Proposal 0" Fulltext search expression should not be specif...	I don't believe this is a core use case that is necessary to get done for 1.0
Patrick Ryan	IBM	--
Derek Carr	IBM	--
Gregory Melahn	IBM	Fulltext search expression should not be specif...
Scott Conroy	Individual	--
Gershon Janssen	Individual	--
Gary Gershon	Individual	--
Boris Kraft	Magnolia International AG	--
Sameer Charles	Magnolia International AG	--
Dustin Friesenhahn	Microsoft Corporation	--
Ethan Gur-esh	Microsoft Corporation	--
Pat Miller	Microsoft Corporation	--
Florent Guillaume	Nuxeo	"Proposal 0"	There is great need for clients to know what syntax to use, but there are too many pitfalls in specifying a complex syntax, therefore I feel only Proposal 0 is acceptable.
Robin Cover	OASIS	--
James Bryce Clark	OASIS	--
Jens Huebel	Open Text Corporation	"Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Florian Mueller	Open Text Corporation	"Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Ryan McVeigh	Oracle Corporation	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Steve Roth	Oracle Corporation	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
David Pitfield	Oracle Corporation	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Alison Macmillan	Oracle Corporation	"Proposal 0" "Proposal 1" "Proposal 2"
Eric Chan	Oracle Corporation	--
Madi Solomon	Pearson PLC	--
Stephan Friedl	Quark	--
Martin Hermes	SAP AG	--
Paul Goetz	SAP AG	--
Stephan Klevenz	SAP AG	--
Volker John	Saperion AG	--
Mark Carlson	Sun Microsystems	--
Ijonas Kisselbach	Vamosa	--
Conleth O'Connell	Vignette Corporation	--