< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Straw poll on whether to allow "mutating attributes" in KMIP V1.0.

This straw poll is intended to gather input on what approach should be taken in allowing or restricting mutating attributes in KMIP V1.0. See the email posting from Alan Frindell on 10-June, "[kmip] Mutating Attributes" for discussion of this question.

 [ ]  No change to the current specification. Servers are allowed to mutate any attribute.
 [ ]  Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the list of attributes that a server is allowed to mutate.
 [ ]  Modify KMIP specification to allow the client to inform the server whether or not it will accept mutated attributes.
 [ ]  Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and 3 above.
Opening:   Thursday, 25 June 2009 @ 02:00 pm EDT
Closing:   Thursday, 2 July 2009 @ 02:00 pm EDT
Group:   OASIS Key Management Interoperability Protocol (KMIP) TC
Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
No change to the current specification. Servers are allowed to mutate any attribute. 0 0%
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the list of attributes that a server is allowed to mutate. 5 31%
Modify KMIP specification to allow the client to inform the server whether or not it will accept mutated attributes. 4 25%
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and 3 above. 7 44%
Eligible members who have voted: 16 of 61 26%
Eligible members who have abstained: 0 of 61 0%
Eligible members who have not voted: 45 of 61 74%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
Tim Tompkins
Aetna
--
 
Dale Moberg
Axway Software
--
 
Marc Hocking
BeCrypt Ltd.
--
 
Scott Kipp
Brocade Communications Systems, Inc.
--
 
Jitendra Singh
Brocade Communications Systems, Inc.
--
 
Tim Bruce
CA
--
 
Don McAlister
Cipheroptics
--
 
Landon Noll
Cisco Systems, Inc.
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the ...
Rob Philpott
EMC Corporation
--
 
Robert Griffin
EMC Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
 
Shyam Mankala
EMC Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
 
Servesh Singh
EMC Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the ...
 
Judith Furlong
EMC Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the ...
 
Peter Zelechoski
Election Systems & Software
Modify KMIP specification to allow the client t...
 
Larry Hofer
Emulex Corporation
--
 
David Lawson
Emulex Corporation
--
 
Brandon Hoff
Emulex Corporation
--
 
Jishnu Mukerji
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Mark Schiller
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Stan Feather
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Amit Raikar
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Indra Fitzgerald
Hewlett-Packard
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
 
Steven Wierenga
Hewlett-Packard
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
Krishna Yellepeddy
IBM
--
 
Gordon Arnold
IBM
--
 
Robert Haas
IBM
--
 
Glen Jaquette
IBM
--
 
Marko Vukolic
IBM
--
 
Rene Pawlitzek
IBM
--
 
Mathias Bjorkqvist
IBM
--
 
Todd Arnold
IBM
--
 
Bruce Rich
IBM
Modify KMIP specification to allow the client t...
 
Marc Massar
Individual
--
 
Benjamin Tomhave
Individual
--
 
Walt Hubis
LSI Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to allow the client t...
 
Graydon Dodson
Lexmark International Inc.
--
 
Thomas Hardjono
M.I.T.
--
 
Hyrum Mills
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Elaine Barker
NIST
--
 
Subhash Sankuratripati
NetApp
--
 
Paolo Bezoari
NetApp
--
 
Robin Cover
OASIS
--
 
Will Price
PGP Corporation
--
 
Jon Callas
PGP Corporation
--
 
Upendra Mardikar
PayPal Inc.
--
 
Rod Wideman
Quantum Corporation
Modify KMIP specification to allow the client t...
Anil Saldhana
Red Hat
--
 
Alan Frindell
SafeNet, Inc.
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
Chris Dunn
SafeNet, Inc.
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the ...
 
Grace Zhang
Skyworth TTG Holdings Limited
--
 
Sandy Stewart
Sun Microsystems
--
 
Wyllys Ingersoll
Sun Microsystems
--
 
Scott Rotondo
Sun Microsystems
--
 
Matthew Ball
Sun Microsystems
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
 
Tom Clifford
Symantec Corp.
--
 
Marcus Streets
Thales e-Security
--
 
Kevin Bocek
Thales e-Security
--
 
Jonathan Geater
Thales e-Security
Modify KMIP specification to include both 2 and...
Robert Lockhart
Thales e-Security
Modify KMIP specification to make explicit the ...
Paul Turner
Venafi, Inc.
--
 
Peter Bartok
Venafi, Inc.
--