OASIS Open: Committees

Asymmetric key profile related changes to KMIP specification

Accept the proposal(s) for:
Rekey of asymmetric key pairs & allowing the certify and re-certify operations without submitting the actual key or certificate

as proposed by Judy Furlong, EMC

Amendment Posted on Thursday, 8 April 2010:
Re-opening 'cos of the holiday weekend

[ ]	Yes
[ ]	No
[ ]	Abstain

Opening:		Monday, 22 March 2010 @ 01:00 am EDT
Closing:		Thursday, 15 April 2010 @ 10:00 am EDT
Group:		OASIS Key Management Interoperability Protocol (KMIP) TC

Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name	Type	Date	Action
Proposal for Making Submission of a Certificate Request in the Certify and Re-certify Operations Opt (81K)	Reference Document	2010-03-04	Details
Proposal for Supporting Rekey of Asymmetric Key Pairs (175K)	Reference Document	2010-03-04	Details

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
Yes	21	100%
No	0	0%
Abstain	0

Eligible members who have voted:	21 of 38	55%
Eligible members who have abstained:	0 of 38	0%
Eligible members who have not voted:	17 of 38	45%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Scott Kipp	Brocade Communications Systems, Inc.	Yes
Landon Noll	Cisco Systems, Inc.	--
Robert Griffin	EMC Corporation	--
Shyam Mankala	EMC Corporation	--
Judith Furlong	EMC Corporation	Yes
Peter Zelechoski	Election Systems & Software	Yes
Bob Nixon	Emulex Corporation	--
Brandon Hoff	Emulex Corporation	--
Larry Hofer	Emulex Corporation	Yes
David Lawson	Emulex Corporation	Yes
Steven Wierenga	Hewlett-Packard	--
Stan Feather	Hewlett-Packard	Yes
Indra Fitzgerald	Hewlett-Packard	Yes	In the certificate request proposal, the note (*) added to table 121 should also be added to table 125.
Krishna Yellepeddy	IBM	--
Bruce Rich	IBM	--
Gordon Arnold	IBM	--
Rene Pawlitzek	IBM	--
Robert Haas	IBM	Yes
Marko Vukolic	IBM	Yes
Mathias Bjorkqvist	IBM	Yes
Sean Turner	International Electronic Communication Ana...	Yes
Walt Hubis	LSI Corporation	Yes
Thomas Hardjono	M.I.T.	Yes
Elaine Barker	NIST	--
Kelley Burgin	National Security Agency	Yes	"Supporting Rekey" * There seems to be no reason for the order of table yy. Suggest ordering by referenced section number. (I realize the symmetric key table has no reason) * Table yy, in the Actio
Subhash Sankuratripati	NetApp	--
Matthew Ball	Oracle Corporation	--
Hal Lockhart	Oracle Corporation	Yes
Mike Allen	PGP Corporation	Yes
Rod Wideman	Quantum Corporation	Yes	Some Editorial nits: a) In the re-key proposal, there is inconsistent capitalization of "Re-Key Key" b) In the cert request proposal, instead of using an asterisk for the note, recommend using a l
Paul Earsy	SafeNet, Inc.	Yes
Alan Frindell	SafeNet, Inc.	Yes	The second proposal introduces the word 'must' in the note below table 121. I think this should be a SHALL? Also perhaps we should clarify that though Certificate Type and Certificate Request are bo
Tom Clifford	Symantec Corp.	--
Jay Jacobs	Target Corporation	Yes
Jonathan Geater	Thales e-Security	--
Marcus Streets	Thales e-Security	Yes
Paul Turner	Venafi, Inc.	--
Saikat Saha	Vormetric, Inc.	--