< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Straw poll - Behavior of Get_attributes

In the case where a client requests a list of attributes, what should the server behavior be when an attribute is repeated more than once?

 [ ]  server must reject the Get_attributes request if client repeats an attribute
 [ ]  server must return only a single answer for each attribute, even if repeated
 [ ]  server must return an answer for each attribute in the request, including repeated attributes
 [ ]  leave it unspecified so any of the above behaviors are permitted
 [ ]  Other:
Opening:   Wednesday, 1 June 2011 @ 10:00 am EDT
Closing:   Wednesday, 8 June 2011 @ 10:00 am EDT
Group:   OASIS Key Management Interoperability Protocol (KMIP) TC
Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
server must reject the Get_attributes request if client repeats an attribute 1 7%
server must return only a single answer for each attribute, even if repeated 3 21%
server must return an answer for each attribute in the request, including repeated attributes 6 43%
leave it unspecified so any of the above behaviors are permitted 2 14%
Other 2 14%
Eligible members who have voted: 14 of 74 19%
Eligible members who have abstained: 0 of 74 0%
Eligible members who have not voted: 60 of 74 81%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
James Dzierzanowski
American Express CCoE
--
 
Sitaram Inguva
American Express CCoE
--
 
Christina Richards
American Express CCoE
--
 
Dale Moberg
Axway Software
--
 
Tim Bruce
CA Technologies
--
 
Chris Burchett
Credant Technologies, Inc.
--
 
Warren Robbins
Credant Technologies, Inc.
--
 
Boris Schumperli
Cryptomathic
server must reject the Get_attributes request i...
 
Joel Hockey
Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.
leave it unspecified so any of the above behavi...
 
Tim Hudson
Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.
server must return only a single answer for eac...
 
Rob Philpott
EMC
--
 
Robert Griffin
EMC
--
 
Judith Furlong
EMC
--
 
Vinod Duggirala
EMC
--
 
Peter Yee
EMC
--
 
Marko Vukolic
EURECOM
--
 
Peter Zelechoski
Election Systems & Software
server must return an answer for each attribute...
 
Larry Hofer
Emulex Corporation
--
 
David Lawson
Emulex Corporation
--
 
Brandon Hoff
Emulex Corporation
--
 
Bob Nixon
Emulex Corporation
leave it unspecified so any of the above behavi...
 
Somanchi Trinath
Freescale Semiconductor, Inc.
--
 
Sairam Mannidi
Freescale Semiconductor, Inc.
--
 
Jishnu Mukerji
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Mark Schiller
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Stan Feather
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Kurt Heberlein
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Steven Wierenga
Hewlett-Packard
server must return an answer for each attribute...
 
Indra Fitzgerald
Hewlett-Packard
server must return an answer for each attribute...
 
Krishna Yellepeddy
IBM
--
 
Gordon Arnold
IBM
--
 
Robert Haas
IBM
--
 
Glen Jaquette
IBM
--
 
Mathias Bjorkqvist
IBM
--
 
Todd Arnold
IBM
--
 
John Peck
IBM
--
 
Bruce Rich
IBM
Other: MUST NOT reject the request, may return multiples according to server policy
 
Sean Turner
International Electronic Communication Ana...
--
 
Graydon Dodson
Lexmark International Inc.
--
 
Thomas Hardjono
M.I.T.
--
 
Elaine Barker
NIST
--
 
Kelley Burgin
National Security Agency
--
 
Walt Hubis
NetApp
--
 
Subhash Sankuratripati
NetApp
server must return an answer for each attribute...
 
Robin Cover
OASIS
--
 
Dee Schur
OASIS
--
 
Hal Lockhart
Oracle
--
 
Wyllys Ingersoll
Oracle
--
 
Scott Rotondo
Oracle
--
 
Lars Bagnert
PrimeKey Solutions AB
--
 
Rod Wideman
Quantum Corporation
server must return an answer for each attribute...
 
John Leiseboer
QuintessenceLabs Pty Ltd.
server must return an answer for each attribute...
Anil Saldhana
Red Hat
--
 
Chris Dunn
SafeNet, Inc.
--
 
Alan Frindell
SafeNet, Inc.
--
 
Saikat Saha
SafeNet, Inc.
--
 
James FitzGerald
SafeNet, Inc.
server must return only a single answer for eac...
 
Denis Pochuev
SafeNet, Inc.
server must return only a single answer for eac...
 
Grace Zhang
Skyworth TTG Holdings Limited
--
 
Tom Clifford
Symantec Corp.
--
 
Mike Allen
Symantec Corp.
--
 
Hal Aldridge
Sypris Electronics
--
 
Michael Duren
Sypris Electronics
Other: Give option to reject or return single answer per attribute.
 
Jay Jacobs
Target Corporation
--
 
Jonathan Geater
Thales e-Security
--
 
Marcus Streets
Thales e-Security
--
 
Robert Lockhart
Thales e-Security
--
 
Erica Johnson
UNH Interoperability Laboratory
--
 
Timothy Carlin
UNH Interoperability Laboratory
--
 
Paul Turner
Venafi, Inc.
--
 
Peter Bartok
Venafi, Inc.
--
 
Terence Spies
Voltage Security
--
 
Luther Martin
Voltage Security
--
 
Michael Yoder
Vormetric, Inc.
--