OASIS Open: Committees

Straw poll on template/mutability proposals

Which of the following template/mutabililty proposals do you prefer?

Please identify which of the following 3 alternatives you prefer regarding the proposals for changes to templates and related issues regarding mutability. See references below for links.

[ ]	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
[ ]	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
[ ]	No change related to templates and mutability.

Opening:		Monday, 15 October 2012 @ 05:00 pm EDT
Closing:		Thursday, 25 October 2012 @ 01:00 pm EDT
Group:		OASIS Key Management Interoperability Protocol (KMIP) TC

Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name	Type	Date	Action
Template Proposal - Bruce Rich 11-Oct-2012 (24K)	Document	2012-10-15	Details
Template Proposal - Tim Hudson 11-Oct-2012 (155K)	Document	2012-10-15	Details
02301: Straw poll on template/mutability proposals (50K)	Document	2012-10-25	Details

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
Template Proposal - Bruce Rich	11	28%
Template Proposal - Tim Hudson	29	73%
No change related to templates and mutability.	0	0%

Eligible members who have voted:	40 of 47	85%
Eligible members who have abstained:	0 of 47	0%
Eligible members who have not voted:	7 of 47	15%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Warren Robbins	Credant Technologies, Inc.	--
Boris Schumperli	Cryptomathic	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Tim Hudson	Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Anne Luk	Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Magda Zdunkiewicz	Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Tony Cox	Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Robert Griffin	EMC	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Judith Furlong	EMC	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson	I also agree with the comments raised by Bob L, John and Denis. The Template section of the Usage Guide will need to be modified to reflect the simplications made in Tim's specification proposal.
Steven Wierenga	Hewlett-Packard	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Stan Feather	Hewlett-Packard	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Indra Fitzgerald	Hewlett-Packard	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
John Clark	Hewlett-Packard	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Bryan Olson	Hewlett-Packard	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Krishna Yellepeddy	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Bruce Rich	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Gordon Arnold	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Robert Haas	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Mathias Bjorkqvist	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
John Peck	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Anne Bolgert	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Tom Benjamin	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Satish Sundar	IBM	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Paul Grojean	Individual	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich
Thomas Hardjono	M.I.T.	--
Elaine Barker	NIST	--
Kelley Burgin	National Security Agency	--
Subhash Sankuratripati	NetApp	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Hal Lockhart	Oracle	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Susan Gleeson	Oracle	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Rod Wideman	Quantum Corporation	--
John Leiseboer	QuintessenceLabs Pty Ltd.	Template Proposal - Bruce Rich	Bruce's proposal should be supported by test case and usage guide changes to demonstrate the various forms of Get, Locate, Get Attributes, Modify Attribute, Delete Attribute, etc. that his changes now
Saikat Saha	SafeNet, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Ajai Puri	SafeNet, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Peter Reed	SafeNet, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Denis Pochuev	SafeNet, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson	Echoing John's comment, I think both proposals would benefit from illustrative test cases as well as clear definitions of the Locate, Add/Mod/Del/Get Attributes behavior. Fundamentally, though, I am i
Mike Allen	Symantec Corp.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Kathy Kriese	Symantec Corp.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Mark Knight	Thales e-Security	--
Nathan Turajski	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Darren Learmonth	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Robert Burns	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Saravanan Ramalingam	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Sameer Yami	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Robert Lockhart	Thales e-Security	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson	After digging through templates as they currently stand and the two proposals, I am still not sure we have any real world use cases for them that cannot be handled by other existing objects and their
Kiran Thota	VMware, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Michael Yoder	Vormetric, Inc.	Template Proposal - Tim Hudson
Neil McEvoy	iFOSSF (International Free and Open Source...	--