< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Approve Web Services Quality Factors Version 1.0 as an OASIS Standard

Should Web Services Quality Factors Version 1.0 from the OASIS Web Services Quality Model TC [1] be approved as an OASIS Standard?

The purpose of Web Services Quality Factors is to provide a standard for quality factors relating to the development, usage and management of web services.

Web services usually have a number of distinguishing characteristics: they are service-oriented, network-based, variously bind-able, loosely-coupled, platform independent, and standard-protocol based. As a result, a web service system requires quality factors unlike those that apply to installation-based software. For example, since the quality of web services can be altered in real-time by the service provider, considering real-time properties of web services is a meaningful factor in describing the quality of a service.

This document presents quality factors for web services with definitions, classifications, and sub-factors case by case. For each quality factor, related specifications are cited with a brief explanation of each. This specification can also be extended to define the quality of SOA systems as well.

URIs
The prose specification document and related files are available here:

Editable source (Authoritative):
http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsqm/WS-Quality-Factors/v1.0/cos01/WS-Quality-Factors-v1.0-cos01.doc

HTML:
http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsqm/WS-Quality-Factors/v1.0/cos01/WS-Quality-Factors-v1.0-cos01.html

PDF:
http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsqm/WS-Quality-Factors/v1.0/cos01/WS-Quality-Factors-v1.0-cos01.pdf

--- Additional information ---

[1] OASIS Web Services Quality Model TC
http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/wsqm/

 [ ]  Yes
 [ ]  No
Opening:   Friday, 22 February 2013 @ 12:00 am UTC
Closing:   Friday, 8 March 2013 @ 11:59 pm UTC
Group:   OASIS organizational voting
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name Type Date Action
* 02366: Approve Web Services Quality Factors Version 1.0 as an OASIS Standard (214K)
Document
2013-03-08
No Access

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
Yes 45 100%
No 0 0%
Eligible companies who have voted: 45 of 311 14%
Eligible companies who have abstained: 0 of 311 0%
Eligible companies who have not voted: 266 of 311 86%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
Colin Hopkinson (Pri)
3M HIS
--
 
Ed Skoviak (Pri)
ACORD Corporation
--
 
Betsy Fanning (Pri)
AIIM
--
 
Massimo Battistella (Pri)
AITI-Associazione Italiana Tesorieri de Im...
--
 
Evgeny Popov (Pri)
APIphany
--
 
Ian Ampleford (Pri)
ARM Limited
--
 
Juha Tiihonen (Pri)
Aalto University Foundation
--
 
Carl Cargill (Pri)
Adobe Systems
--
 
Philippe Allart (Pri)
Adullact
--
 
Flavio Zeni (Pri)
Africa i-Parliaments Action Plan (UN/DESA)
--
 
Francesco Tortorelli (Pri)
Agency for Digital Italy
--
 
Ed Koch (Pri)
Akuacom Inc.
--
 
Michael Brenner (Pri)
Alcatel-Lucent
--
 
John Newton (Pri)
Alfresco Software
--
 
Severin Foreman (Pri)
Altera Corporation
--
 
Harry Rhodes (Pri)
American Health Information Management Ass...
--
 
Jim Price (Pri)
Arizona Supreme Court
--
 
Charles Schulz (Pri)
Ars Aperta
--
 
Micah Hainline (Pri)
Asynchrony Solutions, Inc.
Yes
 
Aviv Siegel (Pri)
AtHoc, Inc.
--
 
Gil Abel (Pri)
Athena Smartcard Solutions, Inc.
--
 
Mohammad Abidi (Pri)
Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG)
--
 
Dan Romascanu (Pri)
Avaya, Inc.
--
 
Erik Rissanen (Pri)
Axiomatics
Yes
 
Dale Moberg (Pri)
Axway Software
--
 
Howard Mason (Pri)
BAE SYSTEMS plc
--
 
Abbie Barbir (Pri)
Bank of America
Yes
 
Alex Wang (Pri)
Beijing Sursen Electronic Technology Co, Ltd
Yes
 
Wang Xuelin (Pri)
Beijing WatchSmart Technologies Co., Ltd.
--
 
Arnaud Martens (Pri)
Belgian SPF Finances
--
 
Christian Sifaqui (Pri)
Biblioteca del Congreso Nacional de Chile
--
 
Kevin Fleming (Pri)
Bloomberg Finance L.P.
--
 
Jim Tivy (Pri)
Bluestream
--
 
William Barnhill (Pri)
Booz Allen Hamilton
--
 
Paul Lipton (Pri)
CA Technologies
--
 
Chris Parker (Pri)
CS Transform Limited
--
 
Mendora Servin (Pri)
California Office of Legislative Counsel
--
 
Doug Allport (Pri)
Canadian Association for Public Alerting a...
--
 
Masahiro Nishio (Pri)
Canon Inc.
--
 
Raul Sanchez-Reillo (Pri)
Carlos III University of Madrid
--
 
Thomas Fahy (Pri)
CellCast Technologies
--
 
Ken Owens (Pri)
CenturyLink
--
 
Brian Spector (Pri)
CertiVox Ltd.
--
 
Sean Shen (Pri)
China Internet Network Information Center(...
Yes
 
Pamela Webber (Pri)
Cisco Systems
--
 
Shishir Pardikar (Pri)
Citrix Systems
--
 
Israel Beniaminy (Pri)
ClickSoftware Technologies Ltd.
--
 
Duncan Johnston-Watt (Pri)
Cloudsoft Corporation Limited
--
 
Mavis Cournane (Pri)
Cognitran
--
 
Balaji Sethuraman (Pri)
Cognizant Technology Solutions
--
 
Sissi Closs (Pri)
Comet Communication
--
 
JoAnn Hackos (Pri)
Comtech Services, Inc.
--
 
Martijn Kaag (Pri)
Connectis
--
 
Oscar Burgos (Pri)
Consorci Administracio Oberta de Catalunya...
--
 
Steffen Frederiksen (Pri)
Content Technologies ApS
--
 
Ron Zimmer (Pri)
Continental Automated Buildings Associatio...
--
 
Mats Bertilsson (Pri)
Corena Sverige AB
--
 
Tom Bruce (Pri)
Cornell Law School, Legal Information Inst...
--
 
Chad La Joie (Pri)
Covisint, a Compuware Company
--
 
Chris Burchett (Pri)
Credant Technologies, Inc.
--
 
Rizwan Mallal (Pri)
Crosscheck Networks, Inc.
--
 
Boris Schumperli (Pri)
Cryptomathic
--
 
Tim Hudson (Pri)
Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.
Yes
 
Sven Rasmussen (Pri)
Danish Agency for Digitisation, Ministry o...
--
 
Cathy Tilton (Pri)
Daon
--
 
Jonathan Sander (Pri)
Dell
--
 
Gordon Aspin (Pri)
Deloitte Consulting LLP
--
 
Juan Cruellas (Pri)
Departamento de Arquitectura de Computado...
Yes
 
Trine Hansen (Pri)
Det Norske Veritas (DNV)
--
 
Andreas Moravec (Pri)
Deutsche Boerse AG
Yes
 
Juergen Emhardt (Pri)
Deutsche Telekom AG
Yes
 
Jens Aabol (Pri)
Difi-Agency for Public Management and eGov...
--
 
Maciej Zaremba (Pri)
Digital Enterprise Research Institute (DER...
--
 
Oyvind Gjorven (Pri)
Directorate of Labour and Welfare Norway
--
 
Tim McGrath (Pri)
Document Engineering Services Limited
Yes
 
Timothy Bennett (Pri)
Drummond Group Inc.
--
 
Nicolas Figay (Pri)
EADS France
--
 
Rob Philpott (Pri)
EMC
Yes
 
Piero De Sabbata (Pri)
ENEA UTT PMI
--
 
Matt Wakefield (Pri)
Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
--
 
Amy Sebring (Pri)
Emergency Information Infrastructure (EIIP)
--
 
Thomas Sigdestad (Pri)
Enonic
--
 
Ken Macdonald (Pri)
Environment Canada
--
 
Carolina Canales-Valenzuela (Pri)
Ericsson
--
 
Claudio Fabiani (Pri)
European Parliament
--
 
Hakan Karden (Pri)
Eurostep AB
--
 
Marco Carrer (Pri)
Eurotech S.p.A.
--
 
Bart Hanssens (Pri)
Fedict
--
 
John Havers (Pri)
First Point Global Pty Ltd.
--
 
Theo Kramer (Pri)
Flame Computing Enterprises
Yes
 
Allan Foster (Pri)
Forgerock Inc.
--
 
Morris Riedel (Pri)
Forschungszentrum Jlich GmbH
--
 
Bob Beims (Pri)
Freescale Semiconductor, Inc.
Yes
 
Motoyuki Watanabe (Pri)
Fuji Xerox Co., Ltd.
--
 
Hiroshi Yoshida (Pri)
Fujitsu Limited
--
 
Pothiraj Selvaraj (Pri)
GCE
--
 
Matthias Lendholt (Pri)
GFZ German Research Centre for Geosciences
--
 
Sean Lockhead (Pri)
GS1
Yes
 
Martijn van Berkum (Pri)
GX Software
--
 
Walter-John Turnes (Pri)
Gemini Security Solutions, Inc.
--
 
Anil John (Pri)
General Services Administration
--
 
Randy Dufault (Pri)
Genus Technologies, LLC
--
 
Shirley-Ann Fiagome (Pri)
Ghana Parliament
--
 
Lewis McGibbney (Pri)
Glasgow Caledonian University
--
 
Will Norris (Pri)
Google Inc.
--
 
Kel Callahan (Pri)
HIPAAT International, Inc.
--
 
Christoph Meinel (Pri)
Hasso Plattner Institute
--
 
Karen Van Hentenryck (Pri)
Health Level Seven, Inc.
--
 
Joel Fleck II (Pri)
Hewlett-Packard
--
 
Arje Cahn (Pri)
Hippo B.V.
--
 
Zhexuan Song (Pri)
Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
Yes
 
Dave Ings (Pri)
IBM
--
 
Werner Joerg (Pri)
IEM
--
 
Andreas Mueller (Pri)
IIT Software GmbH
--
 
Angus Telfer (Pri)
INETCO Systems Ltd.
--
 
Robin Gorris (Pri)
IS4U
--
 
Max Pucher (Pri)
ISIS Papyrus America Inc.
Yes
 
Patrick Durusau (Pri)
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC34
Yes
 
Rich Dewey (Pri)
ISO/RTO Council (IRC)
--
 
Mary Ruddy (Pri)
Identity Commons
--
 
Christof Marti (Pri)
InIT-Institute for Applied Information Tec...
--
 
Jia Dexing (Pri)
Inspur Software Co., Ltd.
--
 
Markus Jung (Pri)
Institute of Computer Aided Automation
--
 
Shahrokh Shahidzadeh (Pri)
Intel Corporation
--
 
John Heinen (Pri)
Intermedix Corporation
--
 
Christoper Bonatti (Pri)
International Electronic Communication Ana...
--
 
Michael Steidl (Pri)
International Press Telecommunications Cou...
--
 
Lucy Lynch (Pri)
Internet Society (ISOC)
--
 
Ken Klingenstein (Pri)
Internet2
--
 
Allan Beck (Pri)
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
--
 
Serge Huber (Pri)
Jahia Solutions Group SA
--
 
Brynn Mow (Pri)
Jericho Systems
--
 
Thomas Smith (Pri)
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
Yes
 
Patrick Bosek (Pri)
Jorsek
--
 
Michael Alexandrou (Pri)
Judicial Council of Georgia
--
 
David Sawyer (Pri)
JumpSoft
--
 
Tom Magliery (Pri)
JustSystems Canada, Inc.
--
 
Jos van den Oever (Pri)
KDE e.V.
--
 
John Fallows (Pri)
Kaazing
--
 
Michael Murungi (Pri)
Kenya National Council for Law Reporting
--
 
Sarah Schacht (Pri)
Knowledge As Power
--
 
Yasuji Takeuchi (Pri)
Konica Minolta Business Technologies, Inc.
--
 
John Ruegg (Pri)
LA County Information Systems Advisory Body
--
 
Deb Bissantz (Pri)
LSI Corporation
Yes
 
Carsten Schmidt (Pri)
Land Nordrhein-Westfalen
--
 
Kari Korpela (Pri)
Lappeenranta University of Technology
--
 
Don Larson (Pri)
Larson Software Technology, Inc.
--
 
Girish Ghatikar (Pri)
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
--
 
Bassel Dohaini (Pri)
Lebanese Parliament
--
 
Laurel Shifrin (Pri)
LexisNexis, a Division of Reed Elsevier
--
 
Paul Menard (Pri)
Lexmark International Inc.
--
 
Ray Denenberg (Pri)
Library of Congress
Yes
 
James Falkner (Pri)
Liferay, Inc.
--
 
Eric Blassin (Pri)
Lionbridge
--
 
Reinhard Schaler (Pri)
Localisation Research Centre
--
 
Melvin Greer (Pri)
Lockheed Martin
--
 
Jeremy Roberts (Pri)
LonMark International
Yes
 
Thomas Hardjono (Pri)
M.I.T.
--
 
Joseph Wheeler (Pri)
MTG Management Consultants, LLC.
--
 
Philipp Baerfuss (Pri)
Magnolia International Ltd.
--
 
Rick Hutton (Pri)
Maricopa County
--
 
Chris Lippi (Pri)
Mashery
--
 
Saseeta Ramsahye-Rakha (Pri)
Mauritius National Assembly
--
 
Mark Poston (Pri)
Mekon Limited
--
 
Ram Jeyaraman (Pri)
Microsoft
--
 
Scott Herbst (Pri)
Midwest Independent Transmission System Op...
--
 
Robin Gibson (Pri)
Missouri Office of State Courts Admin.
Yes
 
Doraiswamy ('Raj') Rajagopal (Pri)
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Kazmer Koleszar (Pri)
MultiRacio Ltd.
Yes
 
KEIKO MATSUNAGA (Pri)
NEC Corporation
--
 
Eunju Kim (Pri)
NIA (National Information Society Agency)
Yes
 
Guido Governatori (Pri)
NICTA
Yes
 
mary brady (Pri)
NIST
--
 
Robert Bunge (Pri)
NOAA's National Weather Service
--
 
John Walker (Pri)
NXP Semiconductors Netherlands b.v.
--
 
Jim Harris (Pri)
National Center for State Courts
Yes
 
Debby Wallner (Pri)
National Security Agency
--
 
Subhash Sankuratripati (Pri)
NetApp
--
 
Harm-Jan van Burg (Pri)
Netherlands Tax and Customs Administration...
--
 
Rex Brooks (Alt)
Network Centric Operations Industry Consor...
Yes
 
Brian Zink (Pri)
New York Independent System Operator
--
 
Colin Wallis (Pri)
New Zealand Government
Yes
 
Sami Vaskuu (Pri)
Newelo Oy
--
 
Andy Han (Pri)
NextLabs, Inc.
--
 
Frederick Hirsch (Pri)
Nokia Corporation
Yes
 
Timo Perala (Pri)
Nokia Siemens Networks GmbH & Co. KG
--
 
Nat Sakimura (Pri)
Nomura Research Institute, Ltd. (NRI)
--
 
Rae McQuade (Pri)
North American Energy Standards Board
Yes
 
Ken Baclawski (Pri)
Northeastern University
Yes
 
Tor Arne Irgens (Pri)
Norwegian Defence Logistics Organization
--
 
Michael Angelo (Pri)
Novell
--
 
Kristopher Heim (Pri)
Novetta Solutions
--
 
Florent Guillaume (Pri)
Nuxeo
--
 
Don Hamparian (Pri)
OCLC
--
 
Helle Schade-Sorensen (Pri)
OIOXML eBusiness Standardization Group
--
 
Monika Horner (Pri)
OSCRE
--
 
Timothy Allen (Pri)
Oberon Technologies Inc.
--
 
Andrew Watson (Pri)
Object Management Group
--
 
David Connelly (Pri)
Open Applications Group
Yes
 
Carl Reed (Pri)
Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc. (OGC)
--
 
Don Thibeau (Pri)
Open Identity Exchange
--
 
Gary So (Pri)
Open Text Corporation
--
 
Rolf Bienert (Pri)
OpenADR Alliance, Inc.
Yes
 
Suneet Shah (Pri)
OpenIAM, LLC
--
 
Martin Chapman (Pri)
Oracle
--
 
Yasuyuki Nishioka (Pri)
PSLX consortium
--
 
David Helfinstine (Pri)
PTC
--
 
Nihad Elyan (Pri)
Palestinian Legislative Council
--
 
Sylvia Tosar Piaggio (Pri)
Parlamento del Uruguay
--
 
Patrick Harding (Pri)
Ping Identity Corporation
--
 
Kaliya Hamlin (Pri)
Planetwork, Inc.
--
 
Peter Reynolds (Pri)
Polish Association of Translation Agencies...
Yes
 
Himadri Banerjee (Pri)
Previstar Inc.
--
 
Dhiraj Pathak (Pri)
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP:
--
 
Tomas Gustavsson (Pri)
PrimeKey Solutions AB
--
 
Qian Jun (Pri)
Primeton Technologies, Inc.
Yes
 
David Browning (Pri)
Program Manager Information Sharing Enviro...
--
 
Jaime Meritt (Pri)
Progress Software
--
 
Rod Wideman (Pri)
Quantum Corporation
--
 
Jonathan Sander (Pri)
Quest Software
--
 
John Leiseboer (Pri)
QuintessenceLabs Pty Ltd.
--
 
Dick Davidse (Pri)
RFS Holland Holding B.V.
--
 
Serge Quiniou (Pri)
RSD
--
 
Eliot Kimber (Pri)
RSI Content Solutions
Yes
 
Adrian Otto (Pri)
Rackspace Hosting, Inc.
--
 
Michael Prompt (Pri)
Radiant Logic, Inc.
--
 
Mark Little (Pri)
Red Hat
Yes
 
Kevin Brown (Pri)
RenderX, Inc.
--
 
Michael Douglass (Pri)
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
--
 
Johannes Lehtinen (Pri)
Rossum Oy
--
 
Adrian Paschke (Pri)
RuleML, Inc.
--
 
Peter Alterman (Pri)
SAFE-BioPharma Assn
--
 
Sanjay Patil (Pri)
SAP AG
--
 
Nuno Linhares (Pri)
SDL
--
 
Audun Vennesland (Pri)
SINTEF
--
 
Mansour Mazinani (Pri)
SITA SC
--
 
Tatu Ylonen (Pri)
SSH Communications Security (Tectia Corp)
--
 
Serban Coss (Pri)
STMicroelectronics
--
 
Leif Johansson (Pri)
SUNET
--
 
Leif Gyllstrom (Pri)
Saab AB
--
 
Bill Becker (Pri)
SafeNet, Inc.
--
 
Mark Prutsalis (Pri)
Sahana Software Foundation
--
 
Darran Rolls (Pri)
SailPoint Technologies
--
 
Dawn Jutla (Pri)
Saint Mary's University
--
 
Wernher Behrendt (Pri)
Salzburg Research Forschungsgesellschaft
--
 
Francois Jammes (Pri)
Schneider Electric Industries SAS
--
 
Mark Lambiase (Pri)
SecureAuth Corporation
--
 
Dmitry Barinov (Pri)
SecureKey Technologies, Inc.
--
 
Joseph Gittens (Pri)
Security Industry Association
--
 
Carlo Marchetti (Pri)
Senato della Repubblica
--
 
Siddhartha Chandurkar (Pri)
ShepHertz Technologies Pvt.Ltd.
--
 
Marquart FRANZ (Pri)
Siemens AG
--
 
Juergen Totzke (Pri)
Siemens Enterprise Comm. GmbH & Co. KG
--
 
Prasad Yendluri (Pri)
Software AG, Inc.
--
 
Larry Neumann (Pri)
Solace Systems
--
 
Pim van der Eijk (Pri)
Sonnenglanz Consulting
Yes
 
David Jilk (Pri)
Standing Cloud, Inc.
--
 
Steven Pemberton (Pri)
Stichting Centrum voor Wiskunde & Informatica
--
 
Kerstin Wiss-Holmdahl (Pri)
Swedish Association of Local Authorities & Regions
--
 
Mats Elg (Pri)
Swedish Defence Materiel Administration
--
 
David Finkelstein (Pri)
Symantec Corp.
Yes
 
Darren Platt (Pri)
Symplified
--
 
Hal Aldridge (Pri)
Sypris Electronics
--
 
Andrew Johnston (Pri)
TELUS
--
 
Carlo Milono (Pri)
TIBCO Software Inc.
--
 
Daniel Hinderink (Pri)
TYPO3 Association
--
 
Casey Smith (Pri)
Tandent Vision Science, Inc
--
 
Heiko Krumm (Pri)
Technische Universitat Dortmund
--
 
Dana Liedholm (Pri)
Telecommunication Systems, Inc.
--
 
Robert Lockhart (Pri)
Thales e-Security
Yes
 
Kathryn Breininger (Alt)
The Boeing Company
Yes
 
Charles Schulz (Pri)
The Document Foundation
--
 
Paul Blanz (Pri)
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
--
 
Michael Yeung (Pri)
Toshiba America Business Solutions, Inc.
--
 
Patrick Townsend (Pri)
Townsend Security, Inc.
--
 
Mikkel Brun (Pri)
Tradeshift Network Ltd.
--
 
Paul Haines (Pri)
Trane
--
 
Keith Ward (Pri)
Transglobal Secure Collaboration Participa...
--
 
Kenneth Dagg (Pri)
Treasury Board of Canada, Secretariat
--
 
Craig Gemmill (Pri)
Tridium, Inc.
--
 
Dallas Powell (Pri)
Tybera Development Group, Inc.
--
 
Pompeu Romeu (Pri)
UAB Institute of Law and Technology
--
 
Mendy Liu (Pri)
UOML Alliance
--
 
Joseph Mierwa (Pri)
URL Integration
--
 
Jerry Smith (Pri)
US Department of Defense (DoD)
Yes
 
Jeremiah Bruce (Pri)
US Department of Homeland Security
--
 
Ollie Gray (Pri)
US Military Health Services
--
 
James Colson (Pri)
USAMC Logistics Support Activity
--
 
Fred Bbaale (Pri)
Uganda Parliament
Yes
 
Monica Palmirani (Pri)
University of Bologna-CIRSFID
--
 
Philippe Thiran (Pri)
University of Namur (FUNDP)
--
 
Toby Considine (Pri)
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Yes
 
Ron Bowmaster (Pri)
Utah Administrative Office of the Courts
--
 
Ted Streete (Pri)
VCE
--
 
Winston Bumpus (Pri)
VMware, Inc.
--
 
Paul Turner (Pri)
Venafi, Inc.
--
 
Dale Rickards (Pri)
Verizon Business
--
 
John Glaubitz (Pri)
Vertex, Inc.
--
 
John Davis (Pri)
Veterans Health Administration
--
 
Steven Legg (Pri)
ViewDS
--
 
Michael Yoder (Pri)
Vormetric, Inc.
--
 
Paul Fremantle (Pri)
WSO2
--
 
Len Veil (Pri)
Wave Systems Corp.
--
 
Mark Tiggas (Pri)
Wells Fargo
--
 
Drummond Reed (Pri)
XDI.ORG
Yes
 
Anthony Rutkowski (Pri)
Yaana Technologies, LLC
--
 
Alan Conley (Pri)
Zenoss, Inc.
--
 
Ryan McVeigh (Pri)
Zia Consulting, Inc.
--
 
Cameron Hunt (Pri)
bitWorld
--
 
Neil McEvoy (Pri)
iFOSSF (International Free and Open Source...
--
 
Joanne Egner (Pri)
isee systems inc.
--