OASIS Open: Committees

Technical Architecture

Please review, comment and vote for changing TC web page description from:

"Advancing architectural patterns for using Service Oriented Architecture in electronic business"

To:

"Delivering Service Oriented Architecture framework composition guidelines, usage patterns and accompanying technical specifications."

[ ]	Yes
[ ]	No
[ ]	Abstain
[ ]	Other:

Opening:		Friday, 1 April 2005 @ 12:00 pm EST
Closing:		Thursday, 14 April 2005 @ 12:00 pm EDT
Group:		OASIS Electronic Business Service Oriented Architecture (ebSOA) TC

Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
Yes	6	86%
No	1	14%
Abstain	1
Other	0	0%

Eligible members who have voted:	7 of 63	11%
Eligible members who have abstained:	1 of 63	2%
Eligible members who have not voted:	55 of 63	87%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
Matthew Fuchs	Actional Corporation	--
Matthew MacKenzie	Adobe Systems	--
Ed Chase	Adobe Systems	--
Duane Nickull	Adobe Systems	Abstain	I do not liek the wording. I think I know what you mean but wording it as "advancing architectural patterns..." does not seem proper. Perhaps it would be better stated as "Developing service oriented
Sally Fuger	Automotive Industry Action Group (AIAG)	--
Michael Ruiz	BAE SYSTEMS plc	--
Ian Jones	BTplc	--
Chris Hipson	BTplc	--
Frank Martinez	Blue Titan Software	--
Joseph Chiusano	Booz Allen Hamilton	--
Jim Lobban	Canada Customs & Revenue Agency	--
Tony Fletcher	Choreology Ltd	--
Krishna Sankar	Cisco Systems, Inc.	--
Chris House	Cisco Systems, Inc.	--
David Burdett	CommerceOne	--
Jagdip Talla	CrimsonLogic Pte Ltd	--
Dale Moberg	Cyclone Commerce	--
Jeff Turpin	Cyclone Commerce	--
Sacha Schlegel	Cyclone Commerce	--
Michal Zaremba	Digital Enterprise Research Institute (DERI)	--
Kazumasa Takeuchi	Electronic Commerce Promotion Council of J...	--
Katsuhiro Morita	Electronic Commerce Promotion Council of J...	--
Steve Ross-Talbot	Enigmatec Corporation Ltd	--
Hamid Ben Malek	Fujitsu	--
John Jackson	General Motors	Yes
Marion Royal	General Services Administration	--
David Layton	General Services Administration	--
Paul Wong	Individual	--
Paul Spencer	Individual	--
Ravi Akireddy	Individual	--
Sally St. Amand	Individual	--
carl mattocks	Individual	--
Dan Pattyn	Individual	--
John Yunker	Individual	--
Ockert Cameron	Individual	--
Ed Dodds	Individual	--
Anders Tell	Individual	--
Peter Brown	Individual	--
Patrick Hogan	Individual	--
Jesmond Abela	Individual	--
john hardin	Individual	Yes
Rajesh Pradhan	Iopsis Software	--
John Aerts	LA County Information Systems Advisory Body	--
Scott Edson	LA County Information Systems Advisory Body	--
Tim Mathews	LMI Government Consulting	Yes
Ron Schuldt	Lockheed Martin	--
Paul Denning	Mitre Corporation	--
Diane Mularz	Mitre Corporation	--
Wesley McGregor	Public Works and Government Services Canada	Yes
Varun Gupta	Raining Data Corporation	--
Premal Parikh	Raining Data Corporation	--
Ash Parikh	Raining Data Corporation	Yes
Bernd Eckenfels	Seeburger, AG	Yes
Puay Siew Tan	Singapore Institute of Manufacturing Techn...	--
Xingjian Xu	Singapore Institute of Manufacturing Techn...	--
woo pengkeong	Sterling Commerce	--
Monica Martin	Sun Microsystems	--
Kathryn Breininger	The Boeing Company	No	I am uncomfortable with this wording. I don't believe it does not make it distinct enough from the SOA-RM TC. (SOA-RM TC does not yet have a description). I believe it is appropriate to include some
Roberto Pascual	The Infocomm Development Authority of Sing...	--
Jian Zhong	Unisys Corporation	--
Nikolaos Abatzis	Unisys Corporation	--
Patrick Yee	University of Hong Kong	--
Goran Zugic	ebXMLsoft	--