Minutes
Agenda bashing
Anish:
Additional item: If we want to have call next week.
Agenda with the change described above is approved
Meeting minutes approved for the last call.
Resolution: minutes of 2008-09-18 telcon located at http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/sca-bpel/200809/msg00017.html approved
AI reiview
Michael Rowley:
All issues closed/resolved but Issue #8 was not closed.
Michael Rowley:
We should close this issue #8 unless other TC change the version number.
Michael Rowley moves to close issue # 8.
version number is for sca-bpel.
motion is approved: issue #8 is closed.
Resolution: issue #8 is closed with no change to the spec
Martin moves to cancel next weeks call.
Next weeks call cancelled.
Resolution: 2008-10-02 concall cancelled.
Issue #18 discussion:
Michael Rowley:
Proposal is good but we should understand ramification of this proposal.
We should relax the statements on what is testable and what is not.
Martin C:
Agrees so environments might generate component type file in a different manner.
Martin C:
We can still to static type checking.
<Martin C>
we dont want to require all design tools to understand how to introspect all c+i files, but they may do
Anish:
Introspected component type must be conformant as it must follow rules specified.
Anish:
If a non-conformant component type is created then it is tool/user error.
Danny:
moves to accept this proposal.
Michael Rowley proposes an amendment to the proposal
conformance tests can be done at deployment.
Michael Rowley withdraws the amendment.
Danny:
Assembly specification should handle this.
Anish:
we can add there is no restriction to when it is testable.
Michael Rowley:
Agrees with Danny that we should leave this to assembly specification.
Martin Chapman:
Assembly specification already has rules for SCDL.
Dieter:
Is the goal to reject a effective component type file at runtime?
Resolution: proposal located at http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/sca-bpel/200809/msg00019.html for issue 18 is accepted (this does
not resolve the issue)
Anish:
we should re-write section 2.1 with introspection rules.
AI#45 transferred to Michael Rowley (Only section 2.1)
Michael Rowley moves to adjourn meeting.
