Ballot Details: Subcommittee reporting preference (non-binding) (CLOSED)
|Ballot Question||What is the best way for the TC to receive SC reports?|
|Ballot Description||We had a proposal last meeting to limit SC reports to 1 per month (http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/xliff/201203/msg00007.html). The proposal did not receive a second. So I will (for now) conduct a non-binding ballot to see where the group stands on this issue. The proposal can still be formally proposed, seconded, and followed by a binding ballot at any time of course. But perhaps this non-binding ballot will prepare us to most efficiently use TC time to discuss the topic.
Also I'm thinking that moving the SC reports to after the XLIFF 2.0 technical work agenda item could help.
1) Continue to have each SC report at each TC meeting
2) Limit each SC to one-per-month reports at TC meetings
3) Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me
VOTING CLOSED: Sunday, 18 March 2012 @ 2:00 pm ET
|Open Date||Tuesday, 13 March 2012 @ 2:00 pm ET|
|Close Date||Sunday, 18 March 2012 @ 2:00 pm ET|
|Number of votes cast (excluding abstentions)||4|
|Eligible members who have voted||4 of 16||25%|
|Eligible members who have not voted||12 of 16||75%|
|Options with highest number of votes are bold|
|Option||# Votes||% of Total|
|Continue to have each SC report at each TC meeting||0||0%|
|Limit each SC to one-per-month reports at TC meetings||1||25%|
|Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me||3||75%|
|Voter Name||Company||Vote||Time (GMT)||Comments|
|Raya, Rodolfo||Maxprograms||Limit each SC to one-per-month reports at TC meetings||2012-03-13 22:34:00||1|
|Filip, David||Localisation Research Centre||Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me||2012-03-14 07:45:00||1|
|Savourel, Yves||ENLASO Corporation||Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me||2012-03-14 07:17:00|
|Schnabel, Bryan||Individual||Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me||2012-03-13 21:40:00|
|Coady, Shirley||MultiCorpora R&D Inc.||--|
|Lieske, Christian||SAP AG||--|
|Lommel, Arle||Globalization and Localization Association...||--|
|Morado Vazquez, Lucia||Localisation Research Centre||--|
|Pimlott, Andrew||Spartan Consulting||--|
|Ryoo, Jung Woo||Oracle||--|
|Limit each SC to one-per-month reports at TC meetings||When the P&L committee was created, it was specified that the SC would report monthly.
No reporting limit was specified for the Inline SC.
Localisation Research Centre
|Moving the SC reports, as described above satisfies me||In fact we said P&L is to report AT LEAST once in a month. So this should not be interpreted as a limit..