Acting chair: Ralf
Chat transcript from room: odatatc 2017-01-12 0800-1000 PT
Hubert Heijkers (IBM) Mark Biamonte (Progress Software) Matthew Borges (SAP SE) a.k.a. Matt Michael Pizzo (Microsoft) a.k.a. Mike Ralf Handl (SAP SE) Stefan Hagen (Individual) Susam Malaika (IBM) Ted Jones (Red Hat)
Quorum achieved. Details cf. normative attendance sheet for this meeting (event_id=43960).
Notes taken by all and subsequently edited for readability by Stefan.
Mike: Discuss ISO standardization
Ralf: Do this after action items, no further changes
Agenda approved as published with additional item "Discuss ISO standardization".
Minutes approved unchanged as published.
Ralf: Mike and Mark discussed several points in the registration documents
Ralf: Mark will prepare review versions of the documents for week after next
Action #0036 ongoing.
Mike: OASIS Company Membership: https://www.oasis-open.org/member-roster
Ralf: Todo for all TC members working for a sponsor company: prepare press release text - Mike will verify that
Ralf: Assigned to Mike and Hubert
Ralf: Mark to prepare a proposal
Ralf: Assigned to Ralf
All: please send feedback on regular expression syntax for your favorite programming language(s)
Ralf: elaborate use cases, e.g. extending the validation vocabulary
Mike: this would suggest to use the same RE syntax as JSON Schema
Ralf: Hubert volunteers
Ralf: Mike will take care of this
Ted: Have to step away for a 30 minute call (please don't assign anything to me like ODATA-879 while I'm gone)
Ralf: @Ted: will do :-9
Ralf: Mike to check with Jeff Wight on requirements
Ralf: Ralf will prepare proposal, any comments are welcome
Ralf: Evan is working on this
Ralf: Mike will prepare proposal
Ralf: Back to ODATA-919 Specify the result type for each operation based on operator types
Mike: send input/thoughts on Evan's question on relaxing division by zero to allow returning null instead of failing
Ralf: Mark will look into SQL to see how this is dealt with there
Ralf: Mike will take this as he has stakeholders for this feature
Ralf: Matt Borges will prepare a proposal
Ralf: Ralf to contact Martin wrt caching
Ralf: Hubert to close this without action
Ralf: Hubert to check whether existing proposal reflects the discussion in the comments
Ralf: Hubert will take this one
Ralf: Tracking issue, will assign it once 4.01 is feature-complete
Ralf: ODATA-1008 is OPEN
Ralf: Ralf to prepare proposal for compatibly deprecating max
Ralf: Stefan will take this one
Ralf: Close ODATA-1014 without action as it is a duplicate of ODATA-1005
Ralf: ODATA-1015 is OPEN
Hubert: I move to resolve ODATA-1015 by removing all the references in the v4.01 OData documents to Atom. Stefan seconds.
Ralf: ODATA-1015 is resolved with the amended proposal
The returned count MUST NOT be affected by $top, $skip, $orderby, or $expand. Content negotiation using the Accept request header or the $format system query option is not allowed with the path segment /$count.
The system query options $top, $skip, $orderby, $expand, and $format as well as content negotiation using the Accept request header are not allowed with the path segment /$count.
Hubert: disallowing these query options is a breaking change
Mike: clients SHOULD NOT combine these query options with /$count path segments
Mike: Propose change to direction to the client, as in: Clients SHOULD NOT combine system query options $top, $skip, $orderby, $expand, and $format as well as content negotiation using the Accept request header, with the path segment /$count.
Mike: Revised: Clients SHOULD NOT combine system query options $top, $skip, $orderby, $expand, and $format as well as content negotiation using the Accept request header, with the path segment /$count. The result of such a request is undefined.
Mike: further revised: Clients SHOULD NOT combine system query options $top, $skip, $orderby, $expand, and $format with the path segment /$count. The result of such a request is undefined.
Ralf: ODATA-1016 is OPEN
Hubert: I move to resolve ODATA-1016 as per the amended proposal. Mike seconds.
Ralf: ODATA-1016 is RESOLVED with the amended proposal
Mike: clarify that this property can only be used as the left operand
Ralf: ODATA-1017 is OPEN
Ralf: Ralf to prepare proposal
Date and time of meeting agreed
Stefan: Redfish using OData 4.0
Stefan: Do we have a "registry" of OData users/implementers?
Mike: odata.org has an ecosystem page that tries to track usage
Mike: Was engaged more than a year in giving feedback to the redfish project.
Stefan: As an active (fresh) member of Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) OASIS TC, I discussed with Jason Keirstead (IBM) his idea, that an equivalent to specifying a TAXII server might be to "simply" offer CTI content (eg. STIX documents) as an OData service to profit from OData's flexible discovery and navigation options.
Stefan: I am willing to explore this possibility in parallel to supporting the CTI TC in development of STIX and TAXII specifications. In case I need advice or feedback along the way, would there be interest from the members of this TC to provide it?
Stefan: Work with Mike to bring OData to CTI OASIS TC
Meeting adjourned by chair.