OASIS Open

Find connection link within this action item

https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/lexidma/members/action_item.php?action_item_id=3932

1. Administrative

• roll call
  see attendance [John and Ilan are now Voting Memebers, Dirk and Patrick lost voting rights]
• appoint scribe
  dF
• approve minutes from previous meeting
  https://markmail.org/thread/3xrtozksfkxjzdip
  approved

​​2. Material

• DMLex Working Draft DocBook template pending https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma
  • Discussion on normative keywords to be used [skipped]
• DMLex WD Technical discussion
  • Based on technical contributions received by 13th April 2020
    • Two contributions on wiki from Miloš https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma/wiki and John https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma/wiki/Data-Model-based-on-OntoLex-TEI-Lex0
    • John's diagram to be compared with https://markmail.org/thread/va6zm6wfvl25fnaz from Miloš

John presented "union" diagram of TEI Lex-0 and Ontolex Lemon elements. It transpired that the relationships illustrate rather the TEI Lex-0 flexibility than Ontolex prescriptiveness.

Below the diagram TEI Lex-0 based mapping into Ontolex Lemon is sketched.

dF: we need comparative representation of both diagrams, we need to be able to compare especally label and form..

Discussion of design principles:

John: Miloš's proposed design principles seem repetitive, see minimalism and simplicity under different bulllets

dF: While it makes sense that the model should not be affected by appearance, the opposite direction seems a separate issue.. 

John referenced Ontolex "design principles" or general requirements:

https://www.w3.org/community/ontolex/wiki/Goals_and_Scope_of_Ontology-Lexica_Community_Group#General_Requirements_on_the_Model

dF: The Ontolex design principles subscribe to a specific technology (OWL) but there are different principles

dF: IMHO we should stress blind ineroperability, not interoperabilty after a long laundry list of assumtions has been clarified but real interoperanility that allows the lexicographer not to care for the XML or RDF plumbing.. 

Ilan/John/dF: providing an interoperable mapping for both TEI Lex-0 and Ontolex Lemon is among chief objectives

• LEXIDMA TC liaisons and appointement of reps
  • TEI Lex-0 liaison appointement pending [skipped]

3. Closing Admin

• Recap of agreed actions
  Members to edit or propose design principles by next time
  Discussion of design principles to be continued next time
• AOB
• Adjourn [no later than 1400 UTC]

1. Administrative

• roll call
• appoint scribe
• approve minutes from previous meeting
  https://markmail.org/thread/3xrtozksfkxjzdip
   

​​2. Material

• DMLex Working Draft DocBook template pending https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma
  • Discussion on normative keywords to be used
• DMLex WD Technical discussion
  • Based on technical contributions received by 13th April 2020
    • Two contributions on wiki from Miloš https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma/wiki and John https://github.com/oasis-tcs/lexidma/wiki/Data-Model-based-on-OntoLex-TEI-Lex0
    • John's diadram to be compared with https://markmail.org/thread/va6zm6wfvl25fnaz from Miloš
• LEXIDMA TC liaisons and appointement of reps
  • TEI Lex-0 liaison appointement pending

3. Closing Admin

• Recap of agreed actions
• AOB
• Adjourn [no later than 1400 UTC]

• OASIS Open (General Membership)
• General Public