< Return to Ballot details

Vote Details

Ballot: Shall "Rewritable Resource URLs" extension be adopted as an Interface SC approved extension
Company:
Sun Microsystems
Vote:
No
Comment:
Here is the mail snippet

On 20-Nov-08, at 10:30 AM, Nader Oteifa wrote:

>I like the idea of being able to modify a URL on the client including >other types of WSRP URLs. This has always been a problem in WSRP. >However, I think this proposal is too specific in implementation. For >some consumers, storing state as part of the path and not as query >parameters is too restrictive.

This is exactly the concern we have too, Our implementation does not store state in the path.

Hence voting a no for now.

regards
Rajesh T