< Return to Ballot details

Vote Details

Ballot: WSRP v1.0 as an OASIS Standard
Company:
Sun Microsystems
Vote:
Yes
Comment:
Sun votes \'yes\' in spite of the fact that we strenuously object to
the sentence \"A Producer may be discovered through mechanisms such as
[UDDI] or [WSIL], ...\" in WSRP Committee Specification 1.0, 16 July 2003,
page 16.

Referencing WSIL, a proprietary specification that is not in a standards
track, while not mentioning ebXML Registry and Repository, which is an
OASIS standard does not make sense in an OASIS standard like we hope
WSRP will become.

However, we recognize that we should have caught this sooner, certainly
during the open review period, so we do vote positively, in the
expectation that the reference to WSIL will be replaced by a reference
to ebXML RR at the first possible opportunity.