< Return to Ballot details

Vote Details

Ballot: Approve of the TC proceeding with the development of the comment object as a merge of the intel note and opinion objects
Mitre Corporation
I prefer that each object has only one meaning. Consolidating the intel note and opinion into one comment object feels like creating one object with two different meanings. The language in the referenced proposal seems to confirm this too. Specifically, language like:

"If no opinion value is defined then the object represents context without any assertion of agreement or disagreement."

implies that the proposed comment object is really representing two distinct concepts.