Document:
TestAssertionsModel-csd03-diffs

Draft (A preliminary unapproved sketch, outline, or version.)

Details

Submitted By Mr. Jacques Durand on 2011-02-23 4:58 am UTC

Publication Type

None at this time.

Group / Folder

OASIS Test Assertions Guidelines (TAG) TC / Contributions

Modified by

Not modified.

Copy

This document is not a copy.

Technical Contact

None at this time.

Download Count

185

Download Agreement

None at this time.

Description

Several editorial fixes from previous csd and cs01:
- from comment list: use of ISO keywords in Intro section and other non-normative sections.
- from comment list: missing link in ISO ref.
- from comment list: added cross-refs in conformance Clause.
- from comment list: give a name to the different types of implementations /artifacts that must conform. in conformance Clause.
- several (minor) formatting nits, line breaks missing, or that should be removed. Extra-spaces, bold words with non-bold 1st letter, etc.
- unwarranted focus on “conformance profile” in 2.1 (instead, equally refer to module/profile/level as defined in [VAR] ref)
- Some incorrect definitions (see in section 3.2, “language” attribute of the “target”, also unwarranted mention of Conformance profile again, in 3.2 “Prerequisite” – probably forgot to remove this sentence.)
- Some lack of precision on cardinalities (see 2.1, also in 3.2 ref from “testAssertion” to Normative Statement(s)
- Wrong cardinalities for “name” attr of 3.2 “tag” definition, and in 3.2 “variable”.
- lack of definition of what a “property TA” is (3.2. “Reserved tag names” ) and inappropriate style “you can generate…” for a standard. Also inaccurate def of “VersionDrop”.
- In 4.1 “Shared”, undefined acronym (TA).
- Conformance section: need to define subsections titled “Conformance Clause” to stick to most recent updates on the OASIS TC process. Also do not define these as “conformance profiles” (closer to conformance modules, according to [VAR]). Also, inappropriate acronyms (“TA”) used for Test Assertion in such a high level section.