< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Approve Authentication Step-Up Protocol and Metadata Version 1.0 as an OASIS Standard

Should Authentication Step-Up Protocol and Metadata Version 1.0 from the OASIS Electronic Identity Credential Trust Elevation Methods (Trust Elevation) TC [1] be approved as an OASIS Standard?

Electronic Identity Credential Trust Elevation Methods are used to increase assurance in entity identification using authentication events and related entity information for the purpose of risk mitigation when making access control policy decisions. The goals of the Authentication Step-Up Protocol are:

ˇ To propose simple Trust Elevation architectural patterns demonstrating the use of Trust Elevation in modern Access Control architectures.

ˇ To describe a common metadata set, mechanisms and protocol elements for Trust Elevation information exchanges.

ˇ To promote the use of Trust Elevation elements to facilitate standardization among the many technologies and approaches currently in use for credential & authentication risk mitigation.

3 Statements of Use were received from HYPR Biometric Security, Aetna, and Acceptto Corp. [2]

About the TC:

The OASIS Trust Elevation TC works to define a set of standardized protocols that service providers may use to elevate the trust in an electronic identity credential presented to them for authentication. The Trust Elevation TC is intended to respond to suggestions from the public sector, including the U.S. National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace (NSTIC). The Trust Elevation TC promotes interoperability among multiple identity providers--and among multiple identity federations and frameworks--by facilitating clear communication about common and comparable operations to present, evaluate and apply identity [data/assertions] to sets of declared authorization levels.


URIs:

The prose specification document and related files are available here:

Editable source (Authoritative):
http://docs.oasis-open.org/trust-el/trust-el-protocol/v1.0/cos01/trust-el-protocol-v1.0-cos01.docx

HTML:
http://docs.oasis-open.org/trust-el/trust-el-protocol/v1.0/cos01/trust-el-protocol-v1.0-cos01.html

PDF:
http://docs.oasis-open.org/trust-el/trust-el-protocol/v1.0/cos01/trust-el-protocol-v1.0-cos01.pdf

ZIP distribution file (complete):

For your convenience, OASIS provides a complete package of the prose specification and related files in a ZIP distribution file. You can download the ZIP file here:

http://docs.oasis-open.org/trust-el/trust-el-protocol/v1.0/cos01/trust-el-protocol-v1.0-cos01.zip

--- Additional information ---

[1] OASIS Electronic Identity Credential Trust Elevation Methods (Trust Elevation) TC
https://www.oasis-open.org/committees/trust-el/

[2] Statements of use

- HYPR Biometric Security: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/trust-el/email/archives/201701/msg00002.html

- Aetna: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/trust-el/email/archives/201701/msg00003.html

- Acceptto Corp: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/trust-el/email/archives/201701/msg00004.html

 [ ]  Yes
 [ ]  No
Opening:   Thursday, 11 May 2017 @ 12:00 am UTC
Closing:   Wednesday, 24 May 2017 @ 11:59 pm UTC
Group:   OASIS organizational voting
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name Type Date Action
* 03068: Approve Authentication Step-Up Protocol and Metadata Version 1.0 as an OASIS Standard (184K)
Document
2017-05-24
No Access

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
Yes 53 100%
No 0 0%
Eligible companies who have voted: 53 of 262 20%
Eligible companies who have abstained: 0 of 262 0%
Eligible companies who have not voted: 209 of 262 80%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
(Alt)
--
 
Herbert Leitold (Pri)
A-SIT, Zentrum fur sichere Informationstec...
--
 
Florian Skopik (Pri)
AIT Austrian Institute of Technology
--
 
Celso Rodriguez (Pri)
ASG Technologies Group, Inc.
--
 
Jenny Huang (Pri)
AT&T
--
 
scott tester (Pri)
Acme Test Company
--
 
Joss Langford (Pri)
Activinsights Ltd
--
 
Carl Cargill (Pri)
Adobe Systems
--
 
Abbie Barbir (Pri)
Aetna
Yes
 
Nicolas Figay (Pri)
Airbus Group SAS
--
 
John Newton (Pri)
Alfresco Software
--
 
Russell Spitler (Pri)
AlienVault
--
 
John Heywood (Pri)
American University
Yes
 
Andrea Dazols (Pri)
Anomali
--
 
Jim Price (Pri)
Arizona Supreme Court
--
 
Erik Rissanen (Pri)
Axiomatics
--
 
Gunnar Peterson (Pri)
Bank of America
--
 
Vicky Laurens (Pri)
Bank of Montreal
Yes
 
Ryan Stolte (Pri)
Bay Dynamics
--
 
Alvaro Sandoval (Pri)
Biblioteca del Congreso Nacional de Chile
--
 
Jim Tivy (Pri)
Bluestream
--
 
Phillip Windley (Pri)
Brigham Young University OIT
Yes
 
John Crandall (Pri)
Brocade Communications Systems
--
 
Paul Lipton (Pri)
CA Technologies
--
 
Thorsten Behrens (Pri)
CIB labs GmbH
--
 
Alexandre Dulaunoy (Pri)
CIRCL
Yes
 
Sarah Kelley (Pri)
CIS
Yes
 
Fabrizio Barbero (Pri)
CSI Piemonte
--
 
Mendora Servin (Pri)
California Office of Legislative Counsel
--
 
Masahiro Nishio (Pri)
Canon Inc.
--
 
Raul Sanchez-Reillo (Pri)
Carlos III University of Madrid
--
 
Sandra Brown (Pri)
Carnegie Mellon University
--
 
Haibo Li (Pri)
China Electronics Standardization Institute
--
 
Narendra Vad (Pri)
Cisco Systems
--
 
Matthew Reed (Pri)
Coelition
--
 
Dawn Stevens (Pri)
Comtech Services, Inc.
--
 
Martijn Kaag (Pri)
Connectis
--
 
Graham Steel (Pri)
Cryptosense
--
 
Tim Hudson (Pri)
Cryptsoft Pty Ltd.
Yes
 
Stefan Vaillant (Pri)
Cumulocity
--
 
Jane Ginn (Pri)
Cyber Threat Intelligence Network, Inc. (C...
--
 
Dario Forte (Pri)
DFLabs SPA
--
 
Juan Gonzalez (Pri)
DHS Office of Cybersecurity and Communicat...
--
 
Sven Rasmussen (Pri)
Danish Agency for Digitisation, Ministry o...
--
 
Gauthier Fanmuy (Pri)
Dassault Systemes
--
 
Kelly Kanellakis (Pri)
Dell
--
 
Juan Cruellas (Pri)
Departamento de Arquitectura de Computado...
--
 
Andreas Moravec (Pri)
Deutsche Boerse AG
Yes
 
Juergen Emhardt (Pri)
Deutsche Telekom AG
--
 
Jens Aabol (Pri)
Difi-Agency for Public Management and eGov...
--
 
Mette Frydenberg (Pri)
Directorate of Labour and Welfare Norway
--
 
Michael Yatsko (Pri)
DocuSign, Inc.
--
 
Oz Mishli (Pri)
Dyadic Security Ltd.
--
 
Kristen Eberlein (Pri)
Eberlein Consulting LLC
--
 
Joep Gommers (Pri)
EclecticIQ
--
 
Matt Wakefield (Pri)
Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
--
 
Mark Nixon (Pri)
Emerson Process Management
--
 
Thomas Sigdestad (Pri)
Enonic
--
 
Richard Hogue (Pri)
Environment Canada
--
 
Carolina Canales-Valenzuela (Pri)
Ericsson
--
 
Gianluigi Alari (Pri)
European Parliament
--
 
Luc Boutier (Pri)
FastConnect SAS
--
 
Geoffrey Li (Pri)
Feitian Technologies Co., Ltd.
--
 
Chris Ricard (Pri)
Financial Services Information Sharing and...
--
 
Paul Patrick (Pri)
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Joyce Raby (Pri)
Florida Justice Technology Center
--
 
Praveen Yalavarty (Pri)
Ford Motor Company
--
 
Gerald Stueve (Alt)
Fornetix
Yes
 
Daniel Mallmann (Pri)
Forschungszentrum Juelich GmbH
--
 
Derek Manky (Pri)
Fortinet Inc.
--
 
Motoyuki Watanabe (Pri)
Fuji Xerox Co., Ltd.
--
 
Makiko Shimamura (Alt)
Fujitsu Limited
Yes
 
Adam Cason (Pri)
Futurex
--
 
Lionel Causse (Pri)
G2mobility
--
 
Adam Cooper (Pri)
GDS
--
 
Peter Cowap (Pri)
GRCTC
--
 
Sean Lockhead (Pri)
GS1
Yes
 
Juliet Espinosa (Pri)
GS1 Colombia/LOGYCA
--
 
Melanie Knapp (Pri)
George Mason University Law Library
--
 
Eric Burger (Pri)
Georgetown University
Yes
 
Kristina Niedringhaus (Pri)
Georgia State University College of Law Li...
--
 
Shirley-Ann Fiagome (Pri)
Ghana Parliament
Yes
 
Sivan Barzily (Pri)
GigaSpaces Technologies
--
 
Brian Hainey (Pri)
Glasgow Caledonian University
--
 
Will Norris (Pri)
Google Inc.
--
 
George Knecht (Pri)
Green Filing, LLC
--
 
Sun-ho Lee (Pri)
Hancom Secure, Inc.
--
 
Christoph Meinel (Pri)
Hasso Plattner Institute
--
 
Maria Essig (Pri)
Healthwise
Yes
 
Steve Wierenga (Pri)
Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE)
Yes
 
Akihito Sawada (Pri)
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Sheila Thompson (Pri)
Honeycomb Networks
--
 
Ke Zhou (Pri)
HuaZhong University of Science and Technology
--
 
Fang You (Pri)
Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
--
 
Nick Humphrey (Pri)
Huntsman Security
--
 
Riyaz Samnani (Pri)
IAALS
--
 
Dave Ings (Pri)
IBM
--
 
Remi Blancher (Pri)
IDNOMIC
--
 
Patti Aymond (Pri)
IEM
Yes
 
Atsuhiro Goto (Pri)
IISEC
--
 
Ashwini Jarral (Pri)
IJIS Institute
--
 
Nigel Solkhon (Pri)
ISITC Europe
--
 
Keith Schengili-Roberts (Pri)
IXIASOFT
Yes
 
Mary Ruddy (Pri)
Identity Commons
Yes
 
Jeff Fedders (Pri)
Intel Corporation
--
 
John Heinen (Pri)
Intermedix Corporation
--
 
Michael Steidl (Pri)
International Press Telecommunications Cou...
--
 
Steve Olshansky (Pri)
Internet Society (ISOC)
Yes
 
Ken Klingenstein (Pri)
Internet2
Yes
 
Allan Beck (Pri)
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
--
 
Serge Huber (Pri)
Jahia Solutions Group SA
--
 
Thomas Smith (Pri)
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
Yes
 
Ron Beach (Pri)
Journal Technologies
--
 
Jorge Basto (Pri)
Judicial Council of Georgia
--
 
Tom Magliery (Pri)
JustSystems Canada, Inc.
--
 
Camilla Boemann (Pri)
KDE e.V.
--
 
Andre Bereza (Pri)
KRYPTUS
--
 
John Fallows (Pri)
Kaazing
--
 
James Ferguson (Pri)
Kaiser Permanente
--
 
Trey Darley (Pri)
Kingfisher Operations, sprl
--
 
Yasuji Takeuchi (Pri)
Konica Minolta, Inc.
--
 
Mark von Rosing (Pri)
LEADing Practice
--
 
Carsten Schmidt (Pri)
Land Nordrhein-Westfalen
--
 
Ruben Salazar (Pri)
Landis & Gyr
--
 
Marcus Casal (Pri)
Lionbridge
--
 
Reinhard Schaler (Pri)
Localisation Research Centre
--
 
Marc van Hilvoorde (Pri)
Logius
--
 
Allan Thomson (Pri)
LookingGlass
--
 
Snorri Ogata (Pri)
Los Angeles Superior Court
--
 
Thomas Hardjono (Pri)
M.I.T.
Yes
 
Mario Velazquez (Pri)
MDreieck S.A. de C.V.
--
 
Joe Wheeler (Pri)
MTG Management Consultants, LLC.
Yes
 
Kent Landfield (Pri)
McAfee
--
 
Mark Poston (Pri)
Mekon Limited
--
 
Ram Jeyaraman (Pri)
Microsoft
Yes
 
Doraiswamy ('Raj') Rajagopal (Pri)
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Youki Kadobayashi (Pri)
NAIST
--
 
George Johnson (Pri)
NC4
--
 
KEIKO MATSUNAGA (Pri)
NEC Corporation
--
 
Eunju Kim (Pri)
NIA (National Information Society Agency)
--
 
Kevin Mangold (Pri)
NIST
Yes
Mikio Aoyama (Pri)
Nanzan University
--
 
Jim Harris (Pri)
National Center for State Courts
Yes
 
Denise Anderson (Pri)
National Council of ISACs (NCI)
--
 
Mike Boyle (Pri)
National Security Agency
--
 
David Dale (Pri)
NetApp
--
 
Joanna Larivee (Pri)
NetCracker
--
 
Krishna Narayanaswamy (Pri)
Netskope
--
 
Peter Davis (Pri)
Neustar, Inc.
Yes
 
Daniel Riedel (Pri)
New Context Services, Inc.
--
 
James Collier (Pri)
New Zealand Government
--
 
Roger Wigenstam (Pri)
NextLabs, Inc.
--
 
Yaniv Masjedi (Pri)
Nextiva
--
 
Timo Perala (Pri)
Nokia
--
 
Rae McQuade (Pri)
North American Energy Standards Board
Yes
 
Ken Baclawski (Pri)
Northeastern University
--
 
Michael Angelo (Pri)
Novell
--
 
Florent Guillaume (Pri)
Nuxeo
--
 
Scott McGrath (Pri)
OASIS
--
 
Bernhard Josko (Pri)
OFFIS e.V.
--
 
Timothy Allen (Pri)
Oberon Technologies Inc.
--
 
Andrew Watson (Pri)
Object Management Group
--
 
Robert DeFilippis (Pri)
One Legal
--
 
Scott Simmons (Pri)
Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc. (OGC)
Yes
 
Don Thibeau (Pri)
Open Identity Exchange
Yes
 
Rolf Bienert (Pri)
OpenADR Alliance, Inc.
--
 
Martin Chapman (Pri)
Oracle
--
 
Mark Joseph (Pri)
P6R, Inc
--
 
Yasuyuki Nishioka (Pri)
PSLX consortium
--
 
Pushpinder Toor (Pri)
PTC
Yes
 
Chris Chiesa (Pri)
Pacific Disaster Center
--
 
Den Lunev (Pri)
Parallels IP Holdings GmbH
--
 
Sylvia Tosar Piaggio (Pri)
Parlamento del Uruguay
--
 
Aharon Chernin (Pri)
Perch
--
 
Sourabh Satish (Pri)
Phantom
--
 
Peter Reynolds (Pri)
Polish Association of Translation Agencies...
Yes
 
Danilo Ardagna (Pri)
Politecnico di Milano-DEIB
--
 
Rob Hanna (Pri)
Precision Content Authoring Solutions Inc.
--
 
Tomas Gustavsson (Pri)
PrimeKey Solutions AB
Yes
 
Benjamin Taylor (Pri)
Program Manager Information Sharing Enviro...
--
 
Mike Johnson (Pri)
Progress Software
--
 
Han Yong Gang (Pri)
Qihu 360
--
 
Edan Evantal (Pri)
Quali
--
 
John Leiseboer (Pri)
QuintessenceLabs Pty Ltd.
--
 
Jeremy Crawford (Pri)
Real Estate Standards Organization (RESO)
Yes
 
Mark Little (Pri)
Red Hat
Yes
 
Kevin Brown (Pri)
RenderX, Inc.
--
 
Ted Julian (Pri)
Resilient Systems, Inc..
--
 
Drummond Reed (Alt)
Respect Network
Yes
 
Joerg Schwenk (Pri)
Ruhr University Bochum
--
 
John Joergensen (Pri)
Rutgers University School of Law
--
 
Ann Cavoukian (Pri)
Ryerson University
--
 
Peter Alterman (Pri)
SAFE-BioPharma Assn
Yes
 
Sanjay Patil (Pri)
SAP SE
--
 
Nuno Linhares (Pri)
SDL
--
 
Franck Chauvel (Pri)
SINTEF
Yes
 
Leif Johansson (Pri)
SUNET
--
 
Skylar Davis (Pri)
SafeNet, Inc.
--
 
Dawn Jutla (Pri)
Saint Mary's University
Yes
 
Shuyu Lu (Pri)
Sansec
--
 
Igor Baikalov (Pri)
Securonix
--
 
Joseph Brand (Pri)
Semper Fortis Solutions
--
 
Carlo Marchetti (Pri)
Senato della Repubblica
--
 
Rich Reybok (Pri)
ServiceNow
--
 
Marquart FRANZ (Pri)
Siemens AG
--
 
Prasad Yendluri (Pri)
Software AG, Inc.
Yes
 
Larry Neumann (Pri)
Solace Systems
--
 
Pim van der Eijk (Pri)
Sonnenglanz Consulting
Yes
 
Jordan Smith (Pri)
Southern California Edison
--
 
Zack Schmidt (Pri)
SureClinical
--
 
Kerstin Wiss-Holmdahl (Pri)
Swedish Association of Local Authorities & Regions
--
 
Mats Nilsson (Pri)
Swedish Defence Materiel Administration
--
 
Martin Torngren (Pri)
Swedish Royal Institute of Technology
--
 
Bret Jordan (Pri)
Symantec Corp.
--
 
Joe Jarzombek (Pri)
Synopsys
--
 
Andrew Johnston (Pri)
TELUS
Yes
 
Eric Johnson (Pri)
TIBCO Software Inc.
--
 
Olivier Dobberkau (Pri)
TYPO3 Association
Yes
 
Ryan Nappi (Pri)
Tanium
--
 
David Green (Pri)
Tasktop Technologies Inc.
--
 
Martin Eigner (Pri)
Technical University of Kaiserslautern
--
 
Heiko Krumm (Pri)
Technische Universitat Dortmund
Yes
 
Giuseppe Pino (Pri)
Telit Communications S.p.A.
--
 
Robert Lockhart (Pri)
Thales e-Security
--
 
Kathryn Breininger (Pri)
The Boeing Company
Yes
 
Charles Schulz (Pri)
The Document Foundation
--
 
Charles Cooper (Pri)
The Rockley Group, inc.
--
 
Andrew Pendergast (Pri)
ThreatConnect, Inc.
--
 
Ryan Trost (Pri)
ThreatQuotient, Inc.
--
 
Alex Wang (Pri)
Tianjin Sursen Investment Co. Ltd.
--
 
Mikkel Brun (Pri)
Tradeshift Network Ltd.
--
 
Glenn Gasmen (Pri)
Trane
--
 
Craig Gemmill (Pri)
Tridium, Inc.
--
 
David Lewis (Pri)
Trinity College Dublin (ADAPT)
--
 
Chris Roblee (Pri)
TruSTAR Technology
--
 
Jon Running (Pri)
Tyler Technologies, Inc.
--
 
Mona Magathan (Pri)
U.S. Bank
--
 
Ehab Al-Shaer (Pri)
UNCC
--
 
Antonio Brogi (Pri)
UNIPI
--
 
Michael Grimley (Alt)
US Department of Defense (DoD)
Yes
 
Derek Nisco (Pri)
US Department of Homeland Security
--
 
Stefan Wesner (Pri)
Ulm University
--
 
Adam Wyner (Pri)
University of Aberdeen
--
 
Monica Palmirani (Pri)
University of Bologna-CIRSFID
Yes
 
Toby Considine (Pri)
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Yes
 
Dieter Bong (Pri)
Utimaco IS GmbH
Yes
 
Stephen Diamond (Pri)
VMware, Inc.
Yes
 
Robert Coderre (Pri)
VeriSign
--
 
John Davis (Pri)
Veterans Health Administration
Yes
 
Carlos Evia (Pri)
Virginia Tech
--
 
Derek Palma (Pri)
Vnomic
--
 
Saji Thoppil (Pri)
WIPRO Limited
--
 
Thomas Xuelin (Pri)
Watchdata Technologies Pte Ltd.
--
 
Markus Sabadello (Pri)
XDI.ORG
--
 
Matej Artac (Pri)
XLAB
--
 
Li Haidong (Pri)
ZTE
Yes
 
Chip Holden (Pri)
Zenoss, Inc.
--
 
Christian Götz (Pri)
dc-square GmbH
--
 
Bruno Volckaert (Pri)
iMinds-IBCN
--
 
Paul Martini (Pri)
iboss, Inc.
--
 
Danilo Beuche (Pri)
pure-systems GmbH
--
 
Duncan Sparrell (Pri)
sFractal Consulting LLC
Yes