< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Internationalization Ballot

Should the `lang` property (key and populated value) be required on each top-level object, except for observed-data, sighting, and bundle?

The `lang` property represents the language of the translatable text content inside a STIX Object (or Data Marking). That property could either be required for most objects (vote YES) or recommended for most objects (vote NO). Regardless of the ballot, `lang` will not be required on observed-data, sighting, and bundle because there is no translatable text content on those objects.

The objects currently in STIX where the lang property would be required (or recommended) are: Attack Pattern, Campaign, Course of Action, Identity, Indicator, Intrusion Set, Malware, Report, Threat Actor, Tool, Vulnerability, Relationship, and Data Marking. Pending finalization, Intel Note, Opinion, Location, Infrastructure, and Event would also have a required (or recommended) `lang` property (assuming in their final state they include translatable text fields).

Responses:

“Yes (lang is required in most cases)”

“No (lang is recommended in most cases)”

 [ ]  Yes
 [ ]  No
 [ ]  Abstain
Opening:   Friday, 23 June 2017 @ 02:00 pm EDT
Closing:   Friday, 7 July 2017 @ 11:59 pm EDT
Group:   OASIS Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) TC
Ballot has closed.

Referenced Items
Name Type Date Action
Document
2017-07-07

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
Yes 10 22%
No 36 78%
Abstain 0
Eligible members who have voted: 46 of 218 21%
Eligible members who have abstained: 0 of 218 0%
Eligible members who have not voted: 172 of 218 79%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
Florian Skopik
AIT Austrian Institute of Technology
--
 
Roman Fiedler
AIT Austrian Institute of Technology
--
 
Kyle Maxwell
Accenture
--
 
Robert Coderre
Accenture
No
David Crawford
Aetna
--
 
Marcos Orallo
Airbus Group SAS
--
 
Russell Spitler
AlienVault
--
 
Ryan Clough
Anomali
--
 
Wei Huang
Anomali
--
 
Hugh Njemanze
Anomali
--
 
Katie Pelusi
Anomali
--
 
Angela Nichols
Anomali
--
 
Nicholas Hayden
Anomali
No
 
Dean Thompson
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (A...
No
 
Alexander Foley
Bank of America
--
 
Sounil Yu
Bank of America
--
 
Vicky Laurens
Bank of Montreal
--
 
Andras Iklody
CIRCL
--
 
Raphaël Vinot
CIRCL
--
 
Alexandre Dulaunoy
CIRCL
No
Sarah Kelley
CIS
No
 
Pavan Reddy
Cisco Systems
--
 
David McGrew
Cisco Systems
--
 
Omar Santos
Cisco Systems
--
 
Syam Appala
Cisco Systems
--
 
Mark-David McLaughlin
Cisco Systems
--
 
Sam Taghavi Zargar
Cisco Systems
--
 
Jyoti Verma
Cisco Systems
No
 
Ted Bedwell
Cisco Systems
No
 
Doug DePeppe
Cyber Threat Intelligence Network, Inc. (C...
--
 
Ben Othman
Cyber Threat Intelligence Network, Inc. (C...
--
 
David Powell
Cyber Threat Intelligence Network, Inc. (C...
--
 
Jane Ginn
Cyber Threat Intelligence Network, Inc. (C...
No
 
Sean Sobieraj
DHS Office of Cybersecurity and Communicat...
--
 
Marlon Taylor
DHS Office of Cybersecurity and Communicat...
No
 
Will Urbanski
Dell
--
 
Jeff Odom
Dell
--
 
Sreejith Padmajadevi
Dell
--
 
Ravi Sharda
Dell
--
 
Jens Aabol
Difi-Agency for Public Management and eGov...
--
 
Joep Gommers
EclecticIQ
--
 
Rutger Prins
EclecticIQ
--
 
Raymon van der Velde
EclecticIQ
--
 
Marko Dragoljevic
EclecticIQ
--
 
Sergey Polzunov
EclecticIQ
--
 
Andrei Sîrghi
EclecticIQ
--
 
Wouter Bolsterlee
EclecticIQ
No
 
Oliver Gheorghe
EclecticIQ
No
 
Ben Sooter
Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
--
 
Chris Ricard
Financial Services Information Sharing and...
--
 
Scott Shreve
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Anuj Kumar
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Prasad Gaikwad
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Rajeev Jha
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Jon Warren
FireEye, Inc.
--
 
Paul Patrick
FireEye, Inc.
No
 
Phillip Boles
FireEye, Inc.
No
 
Shyamal Pandya
FireEye, Inc.
No
 
Remko Weterings
FireEye, Inc.
No
 
Kenichi Terashita
Fortinet Inc.
--
 
Gavin Chow
Fortinet Inc.
--
 
Steve Fossen
Fortinet Inc.
--
 
Derek Northrope
Fujitsu Limited
--
 
Daisuke Murabayashi
Fujitsu Limited
--
 
Toshitaka Satomi
Fujitsu Limited
--
 
Ryusuke Masuoka
Fujitsu Limited
Yes
 
Adam Cooper
GDS
--
 
Jonathan Algar
GDS
--
 
Iain Brown
GDS
--
 
Mike McLellan
GDS
--
 
Tyrone Nembhard
GDS
--
 
Chris O'Brien
GDS
--
 
James Penman
GDS
--
 
Howard Staple
GDS
--
 
Chris Taylor
GDS
--
 
Laurie Thomson
GDS
--
 
Alastair Treharne
GDS
--
 
Julian White
GDS
--
 
Bethany Yates
GDS
--
 
Robert van Engelen
Genivia
--
 
Eric Burger
Georgetown University
--
 
Mark Risher
Google Inc.
--
 
Allison Miller
Google Inc.
--
 
Akihito Sawada
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Masato Terada
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Yutaka Takami
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Jun Nakanishi
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Kazuo Noguchi
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Yoshihide Kawada
Hitachi, Ltd.
--
 
Nick Humphrey
Huntsman Security
--
 
Peter Allor
IBM
--
 
Sandra Hernandez
IBM
--
 
John Morris
IBM
--
 
Eldan Ben-Haim
IBM
--
 
Laura Rusu
IBM
--
 
Allen Hadden
IBM
--
 
Jason Keirstead
IBM
No
 
Ron Williams
IBM
No
Peter Brown
Individual
--
 
Elysa Jones
Individual
--
 
Jerome Athias
Individual
--
 
Alex Pinto
Individual
--
 
Sanjiv Kalkar
Individual
--
 
Joerg Eschweiler
Individual
--
 
Stefan Hagen
Individual
Yes
 
Terry MacDonald
Individual
Yes
Tim Casey
Intel Corporation
--
 
David Laurance
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
--
 
Pamela Smith
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
--
 
Mark Moss
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
--
 
Julie Modlin
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
--
 
Mark Munoz
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
--
 
Nathan Reller
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics L...
No
 
Russell Culpepper
Kaiser Permanente
--
 
Michael Slavick
Kaiser Permanente
--
 
Beth Pumo
Kaiser Permanente
No
 
Gus Creedon
Logistics Management Institute
Yes
Chris Wood
LookingGlass
--
 
Wesley Brown
LookingGlass
--
 
Allan Thomson
LookingGlass
No
 
Ian Truslove
LookingGlass
No
 
Jamison Day
LookingGlass
No
 
James Cabral
MTG Management Consultants, LLC.
--
 
Kent Landfield
McAfee
--
 
Sean Barnum
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Jon Salwen
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Charles Schmidt
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Desiree Beck
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Nicole Gong
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Larry Rodrigues
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Emmanuelle Vargas-Gonzalez
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Chris Lenk
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Michael Chisholm
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Michael Kouremetis
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Jonathan Baker
Mitre Corporation
No
 
John Wunder
Mitre Corporation
No
 
Ivan Kirillov
Mitre Corporation
No
 
Greg Back
Mitre Corporation
No
 
Alex Tweed
Mitre Corporation
No
 
Richard Struse
Mitre Corporation
No
 
Richard Piazza
Mitre Corporation
Yes
 
Daniel Dye
NC4
--
 
Mark Davidson
NC4
--
 
Benjamin Yates
NC4
--
 
Natalie Suarez
NC4
No
 
Michael Butt
NC4
No
 
John Anderson
NC4
Yes
 
Michael Pepin
NC4
Yes
Takahiro Kakumaru
NEC Corporation
--
 
Lauri Korts-Pärn
NEC Corporation
--
 
Daichi Hasumi
NEC Corporation
--
 
Stephen Banghart
NIST
Yes
 
Scott Algeier
National Council of ISACs (NCI)
--
 
Denise Anderson
National Council of ISACs (NCI)
--
 
Josh Poster
National Council of ISACs (NCI)
--
 
Jessica Fitzgerald-McKay
National Security Agency
--
 
Mike Boyle
National Security Agency
--
 
David Kemp
National Security Agency
--
 
Shaun McCullough
National Security Agency
--
 
Joe Brule
National Security Agency
--
 
Daniel Riedel
New Context Services, Inc.
No
 
Andrew Storms
New Context Services, Inc.
No
 
Christian Hunt
New Context Services, Inc.
No
 
John-Mark Gurney
New Context Services, Inc.
No
Trey Darley
New Context Services, Inc.
No
David Darnell
North American Energy Standards Board
--
 
Stephan Relitz
Northrop Grumman
--
 
Robin Cover
OASIS
--
 
James Bryce Clark
OASIS
--
 
Chet Ensign
OASIS
--
 
Web Master
OASIS
--
 
Cory Casanave
Object Management Group
--
 
Aharon Chernin
Perch
--
 
Dave Eilken
Perch
--
 
Sourabh Satish
Phantom
--
 
John Tolbert
Queralt Inc.
--
 
Ted Julian
Resilient Systems, Inc..
--
 
Joseph Brand
Semper Fortis Solutions
--
 
Thomas Schreck
Siemens AG
--
 
Rob Roel
Southern California Edison
--
 
Dave Cridland
Surevine Ltd.
--
 
Curtis Kostrosky
Symantec Corp.
--
 
Bret Jordan
Symantec Corp.
Yes
Juha Haaga
Synopsys
--
 
Greg Reaume
TELUS
--
 
Alan Steer
TELUS
--
 
Masood Nasir
TELUS
--
 
Crystal Hayes
The Boeing Company
--
 
Andrew Pendergast
ThreatConnect, Inc.
--
 
Jason Spies
ThreatConnect, Inc.
--
 
Cole Iliff
ThreatConnect, Inc.
--
 
Andrew Gidwani
ThreatConnect, Inc.
--
 
Ryan Trost
ThreatQuotient, Inc.
--
 
Nir Yosha
ThreatQuotient, Inc.
--
 
Chris Roblee
TruSTAR Technology
--
 
Patrick Coughlin
TruSTAR Technology
--
 
Mona Magathan
U.S. Bank
--
 
Mark Angel
U.S. Bank
--
 
Brian Fay
U.S. Bank
--
 
Yevgen Sautin
U.S. Bank
--
 
Mark Heidrick
U.S. Bank
--
 
Richard Shok
U.S. Bank
--
 
Joseph Frazier
U.S. Bank
--
 
James Bohling
US Department of Defense (DoD)
--
 
Eoghan Casey
US Department of Defense (DoD)
--
 
Gary Katz
US Department of Defense (DoD)
--
 
Jeffrey Mates
US Department of Defense (DoD)
--
 
Evette Maynard-Noel
US Department of Homeland Security
--
 
Preston Werntz
US Department of Homeland Security
No
 
Eric Osterweil
VeriSign
--
 
Andrew May
ViaSat
--
 
Lee Chieffalo
ViaSat
--
 
Wilson Figueroa
ViaSat
--
 
Patrick Maroney
Wapack Labs LLC
Yes
Ales Cernivec
XLAB
--
 
Anthony Rutkowski
Yanna Technologies LLC
--
 
Paul Martini
iboss, Inc.
--
 
Duncan Sparrell
sFractal Consulting LLC
--