OASIS Open: Committees

Implementors: Resolution of Issue 158

Issue 158 reads: "When an Acknowledgment message and Error message are combined without additional payloads (regardless of the highestSeverity attribute of the included ErrorList element), the service and action described in 4.2.4.3 MUST be used."

If you are an implementer of ebMS 2.x, please choose the best resolution to this issue.

[ ]	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error message.
[ ]	When sending a combined error/ack, our MSH uses the Error service/action values. (s 4.2.4.3)
[ ]	When sending a combined message, our MSH uses the Ack service/action values. (s 6.3.2.7)
[ ]	When sending a combined error/ack, our MSH will use either the Acknowledgement or Error service/action values.

Opening:		Thursday, 8 May 2003 @ 11:00 am PDT
Closing:		Saturday, 24 May 2003 @ 11:00 am PDT
Group:		OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC

Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option	# Votes	% of Total
Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error message.	13	100%
When sending a combined error/ack, our MSH uses the Error service/action values. (s 4.2.4.3)	0	0%
When sending a combined message, our MSH uses the Ack service/action values. (s 6.3.2.7)	0	0%
When sending a combined error/ack, our MSH will use either the Acknowledgement or Error service/action values.	0	0%

Eligible members who have voted:	13 of 112	12%
Eligible members who have abstained:	0 of 112	0%
Eligible members who have not voted:	99 of 112	88%

Voting Details

Voter	Company	Vote	Reference Document and/or Comment
helmut siemon	Accenture	--
Komal Mangtani	BEA Systems, Inc.	--
Bruce Stephens	BEA Systems, Inc.	--
Per Vorm	BEA Systems, Inc.	--
Gavenraj Sodhi	Business Layers	--
Peter Furniss	Choreology Ltd	--
Krishna Sankar	Cisco Systems	--
Mark Day	Cisco Systems	--
Zahid Ahmed	CommerceOne	--
David Burdett	CommerceOne	--
M Ham	ContentGuard	--
Martin Sachs	Cyclone Commerce	--
Dale Moberg	Cyclone Commerce	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Jeff Turpin	Cyclone Commerce	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
aaron aaron	Drummond Group Inc.	--
mike Dillon	Drummond Group Inc.	--
rvd2 rvd2	Drummond Group Inc.	--
franciosi franciosi	EAN International	--
Jacques Durand	Fujitsu	--
Masayoshi Shimamura	Fujitsu	--
J Durand	Fujitsu	--
iwasa iwasa	Fujitsu	--
jeffery eck	Global Exchange Services	--
michael hickman	Global Exchange Services	--
Robert Miller	Global Exchange Services	--
Paul Kirk	Hewlett-Packard	--
Scott Hinkelman	IBM	--
John Ibbotson	IBM	--
Robert Kearney	IBM	--
chrisfer chrisfer	IBM	--
Pyounguk Cho	IONA	--
Venkat Danda	IONA	--
david abraham	IONA	--
Prakash Sinha	IONA	--
T Lee	IONA	--
Richard Brooks	Individual	--
Mark Klamerus	Individual	--
Brian Hayes	Individual	--
Lars Abrell	Individual	--
P. Gannon	Individual	--
Ian Jones	Individual	--
Yukinori Saito	Individual	--
bill Chessman	Individual	--
Paul Wong	Individual	--
Nikola Stojanovic	Individual	--
Jason Christensen	Individual	--
Sean Mickey	Individual	--
Duane Nickull	Individual	--
Ralph Berwanger	Individual	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Matthew MacKenzie	Individual	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Pina Hirano	Infoteria	--
rahul guha	Intel	--
cv vick	Intel	--
Hrishi Joshi	Iopsis Software	--
Eric van Lydegraf	Kinzan	--
C Barnes	Kinzan	--
P Walani	Kinzan	--
yunjh yunjh	Korean National Computerization Agency	--
John Aerts	LA County Information Systems Advisory Body	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Kim Lambert	Logistics Management Institute	--
David Smiley	Mercator Software	--
Jim Clark	Microsoft Corporation	--
D Welsh	Microsoft Corporation	--
Takashi Kojo	NEC Corporation	--
Hisashi Shimamura	NEC Corporation	--
Dennis Chang	NII Enterprise Promotion Association	--
carolyn Tsai	NII Enterprise Promotion Association	--
kyle kyle	NII Enterprise Promotion Association	--
Kuo-Chang Lin	NII Enterprise Promotion Association	--
Michael Kass	NIST	--
Christopher Casgar	Nervewire	--
cozkaynak cozkaynak	Nervewire	--
Patrick R. Felsted	Novell	--
Scott Ivie	Novell	--
Garret Minakawa	Oracle	--
Thomas Becker	SAP	--
Mirko Buholzer	SAP	--
Gunther Stuhec	SAP	--
Sinisa Zimek	SAP	--
Bhagyesh Hede	SAP	--
catherine plummer	Search Group, Inc.	--
Colleen Evans	Sonic Software	--
Suresh Damodaran	Sterling Commerce	--
Sanjay Cherian	Sterling Commerce	--
Brian Gibb	Sterling Commerce	--
woo pengkeong	Sterling Commerce	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Farrukh Najmi	Sun Microsystems	--
Monica Martin	Sun Microsystems	--
keith babo	Sun Microsystems	--
sylvain duloutre	Sun Microsystems	--
Nicholas Kassem	Sun Microsystems	--
rajesh koilpillai	Sun Microsystems	--
Nagaraj Kulkarni	Sun Microsystems	--
Uday Subbarayan	Sun Microsystems	--
Mike Wright	Sun Microsystems	--
Doug Bunting	Sun Microsystems	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Pete Wenzel	Sun Microsystems	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Lisa Lew	Sybase	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Himagiri Mukkamala	Sybase	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
hhsi hhsi	Sybase	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
Cliff Collins	Sybase	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...	I think it is confusing to include an error with an ack. An ack could be signed with digital references which makes it a receipt for non-repudiation. If the receiver fails to validate the signature in
Mark Potts	Talking Blocks	--
Sally Wang	The Bankers Association of ROC	--
Arvola Chan	Tibco	--
M Wang	Tibco	Our MSH will never send a combined Ack + Error ...
j barnett	US Defense Information Systems Agency	--
cyng cyng	University of Hong Kong	--
kcyee kcyee	University of Hong Kong	--
Engkee Wang	Vitria	--
aramani aramani	Vitria	--
Prasad Yendluri	webMethods, Inc.	--
yguo yguo	webMethods, Inc.	--