< Home | Return to Ballot listing

Ballot Details    TC Member Ballot View
Charter clarification proposal

MOTION:
Shall the charter of the OASIS WS-SX TC be clarified as follows?

(1) Modify the following sentence in the charter:
"c. Specifying the scope of each returned security token using WS-Policy [5] ."

TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
"c. Specifying the scope of each requested and returned security token using WS-Policy [5] (e.g. wsa:endpointReference)."

(2) After the following sentence in the charter:
"j. Specifying characteristics of the requested type of keys."

ADD THE FOLLOWING NEW TEXT:
"k. Enabling additional negotiation and challenge protocol mechanisms to be used (e.g. SASL mechanisms, SPNEGO) initiated by either client or server."

(3) Modify the following sentence in the charter:
"b/2. Actions and elements for responding with a renewed token."

TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
"b/2. Actions and elements for responding with a renewed token (or tokens)."

(4) Modify the following sentence in the charter:
"b/2. Actions and elements for responding about the validity of a token."

TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
"b/2. Actions and elements for responding about the validity of a token (or tokens)."

(5) After the following sentence in the charter:
"7. Definition of APIs"

ADD THE FOLLOWING NEW TEXT:
"8. Definition of additional negotiation and challenge protocol mechanisms.
9. Developing the roadmaps [15], [16] or other specifications mentioned in those roadmaps, beyond the material listed explicitly as within the scope of this charter."

(6) Modify the following sentence in the charter:
"e. Properties for indication the type of entropy mechanism required in a negotiation sequence (as defined in WS-Trust [3])"

TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

"e. Properties for indicating the type of entropy mechanism required in a negotiation sequence (as defined in WS-Trust [3])"

 [ ]  Yes
 [ ]  No
 [ ]  Abstain
Opening:   Thursday, 5 January 2006 @ 12:00 pm EST
Closing:   Tuesday, 17 January 2006 @ 11:45 pm EST
Group:   OASIS Web Services Secure Exchange (WS-SX) TC
Ballot has closed.

Voting Details

Voting Summary

Options with highest number of votes are bold

Option # Votes % of Total
Yes 56 100%
No 0 0%
Abstain 0
Eligible members who have voted: 56 of 56 100%
Eligible members who have abstained: 0 of 56 0%
Eligible members who have not voted: 0 of 56 0%

Voting Details

Voter Company VoteReference Document and/or Comment
Duane Nickull
Adobe Systems
Yes
 
Joe Smith
Apani Networks
Yes
 
Frank Siebenlist
Argonne National Laboratory
Yes
 
Hal Lockhart
BEA Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Corinna Witt
BEA Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Denis Pilipchuk
BEA Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Jong Lee
BEA Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Rich Levinson
Computer Associates
--
 
Dana Kaufman
Forum Systems, Inc.
Yes
 
Toshihiro Nishimura
Fujitsu Limited
Yes
 
Irving Reid
Hewlett-Packard
Yes
 
Ching-Yun (C.Y.) Chao
IBM
--
 
Kelvin Lawrence
IBM
Yes
 
Michael McIntosh
IBM
Yes
 
Michael Perks
IBM
Yes
 
Donal Arundel
IONA Technologies
Yes
 
Fred Dushin
IONA Technologies
Yes
 
Bob Morgan
Internet2
Yes
 
Scott Cantor
Internet2
Yes
 
Mark Little
JBoss Inc.
Yes
 
Mike Lyons
Layer 7 Technologies Inc.
Yes
 
Paul Cotton
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Chris Kaler
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Christopher Kurt
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Vijay Gajjala
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Colleen Evans
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Jorgen Thelin
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Martin Gudgin
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Kyle Young
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Marc Goodner
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Jonathan Marsh
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Asir Vedamuthu
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Jan Alexander
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Mark Fussell
Microsoft Corporation
Yes
 
Norman Brickman
Mitre Corporation
--
 
Jeff Hodges
Neustar, Inc.
Yes
 
Frederick Hirsch
Nokia Corporation
Yes
 
Paul Knight
Nortel Networks Limited
Yes
 
Lloyd Burch
Novell
Yes
 
Steve Carter
Novell
Yes
 
Martin Chapman
Oracle Corporation
--
 
jeff mischkinsky
Oracle Corporation
Yes
 
Alex Hristov
Otecia Incorporated
Yes
 
John Hughes
PA Consulting
Yes
 
Darren Platt
Ping Identity Corporation
Yes
 
Rob Philpott
RSA Security
Yes
 
Andrew Nash
Reactivity, Inc.
--
 
Martijn de Boer
SAP AG
--
 
Martin Raepple
SAP AG
Yes
 
Tony Gullotta
SOA Software Inc.
Yes
 
Eve Maler
Sun Microsystems
Yes
 
Hubert Le Van Gong
Sun Microsystems
Yes
 
Jiandong Guo
Sun Microsystems
Yes
 
Petr Dvorak
Systinet Corp.
Yes
 
Don Adams
Tibco Software Inc.
Yes
 
Hans Granqvist
VeriSign
Yes